Category: Literature

  • Representing Belief in Indian And Aboriginal Cultures

    Part 1   

    Culture and Myth

    Literature is the art of a written work and a well written work achieves a universal appeal. The word ‘literature’ when translated, literally means ‘acquaintance with letters’. It has its origin in the Latin word ‘littera’ which means ‘letter’. It has different meanings depending on the context in which it is used or on the user. It can be applied to any symbolic records, sculptures, and paintings. It deals only with the texts composed of letters and symbols used in a language.

    Cyril Connolly in her work “Enemies of Promise” (1938) defines literature as the art of writing something that will be read twice and compares it to journalistic writings which are likely to be read once. Literature is more interesting than facts which attracts the readers more. It is because, a journalist toils hard in collecting the facts for the sake of the readers, but in turn the people never often look into the seriousness of their writing for newspapers. In contrast to journalism, anything that is put forth or suggested in literature is easily conveyed to the readers. Ezra Pound in an article “The ABC of Reading” (1934) has pointed out the same opinion as literature is news that stays news.

    As society is becoming diverse day by day, literature also keeps increasing accordingly. It comes out with several grand themes that help the readers to comprehend the diversity that has taken place in society in terms of culture in a better way. This leads to rearranging the ideas of the monolithic value system by the people who are the followers of the ancestors. Rearranging is necessary as these ideas have been misplaced by the present age according to its own convenience.

    These kinds of interpretations and change of ideas must be reset as it had been set earlier. The present age must realise the demerits that occur in the change of systems and their ideas. Thus, the writers need mythology, and such has been its entry into the field of literature, irrespective of the literature it deals with. Myths have helped not only literature but other disciplines also. It has been performing the unique role of unifying disciplines with literature.

    Mythologies differ in each culture. Those that prevail are true and acceptable. They represent the deepest desires and fears of human beings. They help people in understanding the mysterious and sometimes frightening form of the universal forces such as seasonal changes, fire, lightening, droughts, flood, and death. Throughout the history of human civilisation, these myths have an integral part in the development of human society. They have no cultural boundaries as they exist in all cultural societies. The saga of a myth has been passed on from one generation to another. It is like the traditional stories which usually involve supernatural or imaginary people that embody popular ideas on natural or social phenomena called “myth”.

    The word ‘myth’ comes from the Latin word “mythos” and from the greek word “muthos” meaning story. “Muthos” in turn comes from the “mu” meaning to make a sound with the mouth. In simple terms, mythology deals with the study of myths. Myth is one of the elements of human heritage. The myths might have probably originated when people started asking questions about the creation of the world and their role in it. The first “myth-makers” might have been wise old men and women who had a magical talent to explain the natural world who were poetic in nature.

    Thus, these myths became a mask for truth, either magical or unrealistic. Regarding the characters, if the hero of the myth happens to be a human being, it is usually not called a myth but a legend. If the stories are about supernatural beings like Gods which appear partly to be a myth, it is a folktale. Myths generally have heroes and other characters who posses’ superpowers, creations, curses and so on.

    The power of the concept of myth has gained through the following adaptability of several common ideas that are used in the analysis of social and political changes as:

                1.To explain the creation of the world

                 2. To explain natural phenomena

                3.To give story form to ancient religious practices

                4. To explain moral lessons and values

                5. To explain history

                6.To express, as dreams do the deepest fears and hopes of the human race.

    When myths are discussed, the term that surfaces to one’s mind is the “symbol”. In a broader sense, a symbol may represent anything which is of great significance. M.H. Abrahams in his A Glossary of Literary terms points out that “this term is applied only to a word or phrases that signify an object or event in turn signifying, or has a reference, beyond itself (311).”

    A symbol may signify anything. For example, ‘the cross’ symbolises salvation, purity, etc. Such significance occurred only after the crucifixion of Christ. This significance reveals that any symbol may have a significance of its own. Accordingly, every myth has its own symbols and each symbol signifies a single meaning or many meanings. Sometimes a symbol is confused with an allegory, but they differ from each other. Coleridge in his The Stateman’s Manual (1852) and Goethe in his Maxims and Reflection have pointed out that these two are different. An allegory may have a specific meaning by itself. As they both point out, allegory signifies an image and concept whereas a symbol signifies only an image that remains indefinite.

    A symbol is the most important and dominating feature in a myth. Symbols are mostly the images of Gods, evil spirits, passions, power and so on to create such symbols; myths have made an extensive use of animals. Almost all the animals are used as symbols to denote power, faith, fear, etc. Some animals like whales, snakes, peacocks, eagles, horses, and elephants symbolise many things. A peacock symbolises pride; an eagle symbolises heroic endeavors; a snake symbolises power, bliss, and fear.     

    Animals are also worshiped by many people. From the pre-modern societies, animal worship has become a common phenomenon. People began worshiping animals, because of myths created by ancestors. In myths when threatened by evil powers, Gods usually took the form of animals to hide themselves from those spirits. Further the ancestors created such myths to save themselves from dangers. From that time people started to worship animals and they also formed animal cults that represent Gods.          

    When such myths are discussed, naturally several superstitions began evolving around them and gained prominence because, myths are the basic belief of the ancestors, created for a practical cause, which in turn have become topsy-turvy. Ironically, these beliefs have become superstitious beliefs.

    Many writers have used these myths and superstitions in their writings. Goethe considers superstition to be the poetry of life. Though most of the people have understood the meaning of myths, yet these basic beliefs have come out in the form of superstitions. These points have been highlighted by some writers in their works and they try to make the people look at mythology in a better way.

    Myths have both positive and negative symbols. Mythologies of India and Australia treat them positively, whereas some mythologies of Greece and Christianity consider them as negative symbols. In Greek mythology, snakes are treated as evil spirits and as the destroyers of the lives of people. In Christian mythology, the snake is represented as the messenger of Satan sent to destroy human life through the ‘fall of man from the Paradise’. In Australian mythology, snakes are seen as protectors, destroyer of law breakers and so on. In contrast to the Australian Aborigines, Hindu mythology worships them. Such are the symbols of snakes that are treated differently in different cultures.

    Such notion about snakes that prevail among different countries are discussed in the project. These serpents are given a significant place in many mythologies. They form an integral part in almost all languages and cultures. They are used to represent many symbols of human life. Further, this thesis also tries to point out the beliefs that have turned out to be superstitions using the ancestral mythical creatures and the stories regarding them of both India and Australia. The influence of these stories to the present superstitious beliefs, are satirised by several writers in their literary works that are found in different languages.

    Alexander Wyclif Reed (1908-1979) of Australia in his book Aboriginal Myths, Legends and Fables (1993) has made an attempt in rewriting the Aboriginal stories making them easier to understand. He has written many books on Aboriginal tales and their legends. His book tries to bring home the idea of the mystic bond that existed between the Aboriginal people, their environment, and their spiritual life of the Dreamtime. Some stories of Reed about snakes have been taken for comparison. Indian writers have also made use of these myths in their works.

    Girish Karnad’s Nagamandala is one such work. He found out a new approach when other writers wanted to choose a subject that looked entirely alien to the manifestation of the native soil. The approach drew historical and mythological sources to tackle the contemporary themes.

    Similar to this are many writers like R.K.Narayan and Kushwant Singh, Tamil writers like Tamizhselvi, etc. They have written some works with snake as their central role of attraction. These writers highlight the basic beliefs and also the prevailing myths about snakes and snake worship. The knowledge of the scientific representation of a snake is essential in order to go deep into the beliefs of the ancestors.

    “Serpent” is a word of Latin origin (serpens, serpentis) which is commonly used in specifically mythical or religious context, signifying a snake that is to be regarded not as mundane natural phenomenon nor as an object of scientific  zoology, but as a bearer of some symbolic values. A snake is a powerful totem animal, the symbol of death and rebirth and the symbol of transformation. It might well be the mascot for the new age. It has been the animal or the symbol of the ancient men and ancestors of some cultures.

    According to the investigation of Sir James Frazer in Comparative Religion and those of Sigmund Freud in Psychology, though extreme, they have shown that human beings tend to use a wider symbolism, even in thinking itself, to cover ideas  they avoid out of fear. Snakes are used to symbolise many aspects of human life. If a snake bites a person in a dream, it is a good sign and symbolises self-revelation. A person’s dream has a purpose in it. To find out the meanings of these dreams, one needs to understand the symbols. The symbols give different meaning to the dreams. Myths play a major role even in the dreams of people in the name of symbols. Hence the belief lies deep in everyone’s life as an outcome of every culture.

    In this context, this article focuses on the role, functions, and the significance of mythology in the lives of native people of Australia and India and how the role of mythology has been misinterpreted through misconceptions and misunderstandings by some people. It points out how in spite of these myths acting as a yardstick in leading a moral life, people look at these myths only in a literal sense. The article hence reinforces the need to study the deeper implications and significance of myths. People gradually step into certain superstitious beliefs that unknowingly affect and shake the basic beliefs of the natives and unstabilise the structure that binds a concrete society. Some writers are aware of these issues and try to stabilise them through their writings.

    An introduction to both Indian and Australian mythologies is beneficial before analysing customs and beliefs. Both the countries have their own reasons for the creation of such mythologies. Indian mythology is not only 1200 B.C old but is also considered to be vast. It is one of the richest elements of Indian culture standing unique in the world. There are infinite number of stories that are passed on from one generation to another through words or scriptures. These stories form the background of Indian mythology, acting as a medium to people to inculcate an interest in Indian culture and to impart values. These stories generally convey subtle facts and maxims to guide people in leading a moral life.    

    Since storytelling is an easy way to approach people, these facts and rules are conveyed easily. There are also stories to denote the same fact. Hence, each version of a story is correct in its own way. The origin of Indian mythology has been from Rig Veda, the old mythological heritage. During this time, people had faith in whatever they wanted to do. They saw God in forms such as –Agni, Vayu and Surya. They relied mostly on abstractions, though it was illusive and in a due course these Gods were given substantial shapes and characters. The two epics, the Ramayana and the Mahabharata were compiled in the late Vedic period.

    They gave rise to the concept of Trimurthi the union of Ani, Vayu and Surya who in Hindu mythology are named as Brahma, Vishnu and Shiva. This concept has become concrete in Indian mythology which is similar to Chritianity’s trinity-the father, the son and the Holy Spirit.

    There are four ages in Indian mythology, comprising Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism and Brahmainic. Om or Aum is the essence of Hinduism which denotes oneness with the supreme, both physically and spiritually. This is the first created sacred sound from which all other sounds were formed. This sound in the Upanishads does not only denote origination but also desolution, including past, present, and future.

    The idea of ‘atma’ or the soul plays an integral part in Hinduism. Sacrifice and performing penance have been the chief forms of worship.  The concept of performing penance with so many years of deep meditation, secluded from the world becomes the topic of interest. The Hindus believe more in Lord Vishnu the preserver and Lord Shiva the destroyer than in Lord Brahma the creator.

    Further, there are many creatures symbolizing different kinds of emotions and also as the vehicles of different Gods. Garuda, the King of birds is the vehicle Lord Vishnu, the peacock and the snake are the symbols of Lord Muruga and so on. From 900 B.C to 500 B.C, as Aryan culture commonly named as the Brahmanic Age gradually dominated Hinduism. When the concept of ‘atma’ came into Hinduism, the Brahmanic caste asserted that Gods need human priests to become powerful. Such was the arrival of the Brahmanic Age that celebrated pride in being the followers of Gods.

    From 500 B.C to 100 the age of Bhuddhism and Jainism came into being and dominated Hinduism.  After several years, the epics the Ramayana and Mahabharata were born and brought back the life of Hinduism. There are many stories that speak about Buddha how he acquired knowledge and strength to live a life of eternity in a spiritual way.

    Thus, all the ages are e considered more powerful and they complement each other with their own myths. But it is noteworthy that all these ages talk about the oneness of human beings with God in different ways.

    Australia is a multicultural society comprising people from all around the world. It always had a mixture of cultures. The most eminent Aboriginal and Torres Strait occupied the islands between Australia and Papua New Guinea, which is now called the Torres Strait. These Indigenous people naves many tribal communities with different languages, cultural and traditional practices. It is believed that before 1788, there existed more than 700 languages within an estimated population of 7,50,000 people. Today the indigenous people comprise 2% as estimated within the population of 410000 in Australia.

    Due to the effects of colonisation, the people were removed from the lands, nativity and their sole identity of culture and languages. Early Australia was completely different from the present Australia. Those indigenous people had no facilities even to travel from place to place like carriages and so on. It had been an unspoilt land where people respected their environment, nature, and everything around them.

    Since they lived the lives of hunters and gatherers of lives, they ensured that they had enough food for future use and made sure that the food was never wasted.  Even women and children were trained to hunt smaller animals and to collect fruits. In order to maintain the fragile environment and due to seasonal variations, they kept roaming through the land. They also made it a point not to hunt at the same place and stored some food whenever they went. The places where these scattered are converted to cities, towns and so on with a mixture of contemporary and traditional thoughts and practices still existing.

    The indigenous cultures of Australia are considered the oldest of all cultures in the world for, they were able to change accordingly. These changes were due to the influence of other country people entering their land for trade. They exchanged not only goods but also songs and dances within their own indigenous people. Though they were adaptable to change and were culturally strong, some indifferences of Europeans affected them resulting in colonisation.

    Archaeological evidences show that indigenous cultures have changed many times accordingly to cope up with the changes of the environment. They were able to survive and struggle against their changes made in their culture by Europeans since 1788. Even before Europeans influence, the indigenous people had contact with other cultures like Dutch, Portuguese navigators and traders in sharing ideas and skills. These influences can be seen in the rock bark paintings.

    The complexity and richness of aboriginal cultures were not clear for the early colonists and hence their government policies were against the interests of the aboriginal people. And they have had profits from the labour of these aboriginals. Many forms and cattle came into their nation without realizing how the indigenous people treat their lands. Their land that was meant for food and spirituality was considered a land of trade alone. Further the colonists even prevented them from speaking their own languages, which resulted in the decrease of native languages from 700 to 250 at present. Yet there are traces of native languages in Australia now.

     When it comes to spirituality, there are many forms in it with different practices and influences by the impact of colonialism, both past and present. There are some indigenous people who believe in the cultures introduced in Australia by the Europeans. Yet, their religious beliefs derived from a scene of belonging to the land, sea and to nature and one’s culture. Their form and expression of spirituality differ from the Aboriginal and the Torres Strait Islanders. The Aboriginal spirituality was based on the stories of the stories of dreaming whereas the Torres Straight Islanders ‘spirituality was based on the stories of Tagai.

    Thus, between the two Aboriginal people’s lives are found much in detail than Tagai. It is because of the significance. So, W.E.H.Stanner , an Australian Anthropologist says, ‘the idea of a sign is thoroughly aboriginal…..’ Likewise art was central to the lives of Aboriginal people and was a product of their Dreaming. Thus, by practicing art singing, dancing, sculpting, and painting. Aboriginal people could assess the dreaming.

    Thus, dreaming had different meaning for different Aboriginal people. It being complex network of knowledge , faith and practices derived from stories of creation , dominates all spiritual and physical aspects of Aboriginal people setting out the structures of society and rules of behaviour in order to maintain the life of the land.

    The Dreamtime governed the way people lived and how they should behave and if rules were flouted, they were punished. The ‘Dreamtime’ or dreaming is often used to describe the time when the earth, and the animals and the human were created. The dreaming is also used by individuals to refer to their own dreaming or their community’s dreaming. The dreaming world was the old time of the ancestors. They emerged from the earth at the time of creation. Time began in the world the moment these supernatural beings were born out of their own eternity.

    The stories tell that the earth was a flat surface, in darkness, dead silent world. Unknown forms of life were asleep, below the surface of the land. Then the supernatural ancestor beings broke through the crust of the earth from below with tumultuous force. The sun rose out of the ground. The land received light for the first time. The supernatural or totemic they resembled creatures or plants and were half human, they moved across the baren surface of the world. They travelled hunted and fought and changed the form of the land. During their journeys they created the landscapes, the mountains, the rivers, the trees, the waterholes, plains, and sand hills. They made all the celestial bodies, The sun, the moon, and the stars. Then wearied from all the activities the mythical creatures sank back into the earth and returned to their state of sleep.

    Such stories help the people to know the origin of the ancestral spirits and where they went to rest. These are the explanations to hoe people came to Australia and the links between the groups throughout Australia. In essence, the dreaming comes from the land. The Aboriginal society people did not own the land, but it was a part of them and part of their duty to respect mother earth.

    Dreaming stories vary throughout Australia and there are different versions on the same theme. Thus, in more recent times there are stories telling the arrival of the first European ships are stories about trading with Macassan fisherman in northern Australia. Tagai is a collection of stories which is the cornerstone of the Torres Straight Islanders’ as sea people sharing a common way of life. Tagai enables orderliness in the world and ensures placement for everything.

     Both the Aboriginal and the Torres Strait Islanders have a complex system of family relations where each person knows their kin and their land. This extension of family relationships formed the core of indigenous kinship systems enabling transmission of culture from one to the other and also in the organization of society.  Story telling in indigenous Australia is still an important way of passing information to people. These stories also in various forms such as music, plays poetry and books keep the traditions and heritage of indigenous Australia alive and also within the wider community paving the way for clearer understanding and awareness among people.

    The Aboriginals believe in two forms of time: two parallel streams of activity. One is the daily objective activity and the other is an infinite spiritual cycle called the dream time  which is more real than the reality itself. It was believed that some people of unusual spiritual powers had contact with dream time.  They also believed the idea of eternity in the dreaming and it bound the life of the individual even before the beginning of his life and continued to exist even after his death.

    Thus, the aborigines believed in the beings while the Europeans believed these cultural ancestors to be magical. When observed deeply, these stories would have many aspects of life to be realised.

  • Booker Prize Award Winners

    1969P H NewbySomething to Answer For (novel)UK
    1970Bernice RubensThe Elected Member (novel)UK
    1970J G FarrellTroubles (novel)UK/Ireland
    1971V S NaipaulIn a Free State (short story)UK/ Trinidad and Tobago
    1972John BergerG (experimental novel)
    1973J G FarrellThe Siege of Krishnapur (novel) UKUK
    1974Nadine GordimerThe Conservationist (novel)South Africa
    1974Stanley MiddletonHoliday (novel) UKUK
    1975Ruth Prawar JhabvalaHeat and Dust (historical novel)UK/ Germany
    1976David StoreySaville (novel) UKUK
    1977Paul ScottStaying On (novel) UKUK
    1978Iris MurdochThe Sea, the Sea (philosophical novel) Ireland/ UKUK
    1979Penelope FitzgeraldOffshore (novel) UKUK
    1980William GoldingRites of Passage (novel) UKUK
    1981Salman RushdieMidnight’s Children (Magic realism)UK/ India
    1982Thomas KeneallySchindler’s Ark (biographical novel)Australia
    1983J M CoetzeeLife & Times of Michael K (novel)South Africa
    1984Anita BrooknerHotel du Lac (novel)UK
    1985Keri HulmeThe Bone People ( A Mystery Novel)New Zealand
    1986Kingsley AmisThe Old Devils (comic novel)UK
    1987Penelope LivelyMoon Tiger (novel)UK/ Egypt
    1988Peter CareyOscar and Lucinda (novel)Australia
    1989Kazuo IshiguroThe Remains of the Day (historical novel)UK/ Japan
    1990A. S. ByattPossession (historical novel)UK
    1991Ben OkriThe Famished Road (Magic realism)Nigeria
    1992Michael OndaatjeThe English Patient (historiographic metafiction)Canada
    1992Barry UnsworthSacred Hunger (Historical novel)UK
    1993Roddy DoylePaddy Clarke Ha Ha Ha (novel)Ireland
    1994James KelmanHow Late It Was, How Late ( stream of consciousness)UK/ Scotland
    1995Pat BarkerThe Ghost Road (war novel)UK
    1996Graham SwiftLast Orders (novel)UK
    1997Arundhati RoyThe God of Small Things (novel)India
    1998Ian McEwanAmsterdam (novel)UK
    1999J. M. CoetzeeDisgrace (novel)South Africa
    2000Margaret AtwoodThe Blind Assassin (historical novel)Canada
    2001Peter CareyTrue History of the Kelly Gang (historical novel)Australia
    2002Yann MartelLife of Pi (Fantasy and adventure novel)Canada
    2003DBC PierreVernon God Little (black comedy)Australia
    2004Alan HollinghurstThe Line of Beauty (historical novel)UK
    2005John BanvilleThe Sea (novel)Ireland
    2006Kiran DesaiThe Inheritance of Loss (novel)India
    2007Anne EnrightThe Gathering (novel)Ireland
    2008Aravind AdigaThe White Tiger (novel)India
    2009Hilary MantelWolf Hall (historical novel)UK
    2010Howard JacobsonThe Finkler Question (comic novel)UK
    2011Julian BarnesThe Sense of an Ending (novel)
    2012Hilary MantelBring Up the Bodies (historical novel)UK
    2013Eleanor CattonThe Luminaries (historical novel)New Zealand
    2014Richard FlanaganThe Narrow Road to the Deep North (historical novel)Australia
    2015Marlon JamesThe Brief History of Seven Killings (historical novel)Jamaica
    2016Paul BeattyThe Sellout (satirical novel)US
    2017George SaundersLincoln in the Bardo (Historical/experimental novel)US
    2018Anna BurnsMilkman (novel)UK
    2019Margaret AtwoodThe Testaments (Dystopian setting, Science fiction)Canada
  • Of Friendship

    The opening lines of Francis Bacon’s essay is a statement of Aristotle, which means that man is naturally gregarious and that it is unnatural to avoid the society unless he performs meditation or has a contemplation of the divine. Bacon says that living in a crowd as in a great city may also loneliness and the lack of true friendship. He makes three points in favour of friendship. It is important to release pent-up emotions, worries, cares and so on and to share these emotions make friendship an essential. Kings and great rulers are lonely people who definitely need such kind of support and emotional release. He gives examples of Sylla and Pompey, Caesar, Brutus, Augustus and Agrippa, and so on. Friends are considered important in spite of having wise children and close relatives and to confide in a true friendship is equally important as a family. It doubles the joys and lessens the burdens in sharing.

    The second aspect is that it allows to clarify ideas and thoughts through discussion and argument. There can be sounder arguments that can allow one to come to a proper decision on the issue. It also allows Anderson to understand and find the weakness and strength of one’s arguments. A friend can also contribute to the judgement and further add his advice as a caution or encouragement. The advice from a friend is more reliable since he knows personally than any other outsiders.

    A friend can be useful in several ways, he can help in advising on the marriage of our children or the completion of work. He can recommend his friend to others and enable him to act or speak without emotional involvement. No man can really afford to be without true friends. This essay is more warm and personal than the essay on love. Plato, Aristotle – to whom he owes much and many writers of the classic have gone deeper into the subject than anything else, yet this is one of his largest essays.

  • Aristotle’s Poetics (Part III)

    Aristotle’s Poetics (Part III)

    The artistic ornament in a diction implies the rhythm, harmony, and song. Rhythm and harmony in verse may be used to develop some parts and song to imply others. They are all designed to enrich the language of the play to make it more effective. There are a few aspects included in a tragedy and omitted in an epic.

    Tragedy

    Form of action

    Needs much greater concentration

    Has all the elements which an epic has

    More effective

    Has music and spectacle

    Reality of presentation

    Unity of action

    The tale is told with the help of living/moving character

    The speeches and action make the tale

    The dramatist is nowhere seen

    Intended to be acted and read

    Epic

    Artistic ornament

    Lengthy

    Certain elements of tragedy are not seen

    More comprehensive and varied

    Lack of music and spectacle

    Reality and unity are missing here

    Has only rhythm, harmony and song

    The narrator of the story is the poet

    The poet is free to speak in his own person or in the likeness of the character. Only to read

    The Structure of the Plot

    A plot is the soul of the tragedy. It rules out a plurality of action. The artistic arrangement of incidents is of prime importance in it.

    Unity of Time

    The tragedy should confine itself as far as possible to a single revolution of the sun, i.e., conformity of the time taken by the events of the place. A good tragic plot has to arouse the emotion of pity and fear in the spectator or the reader. Pity, for the undeserved sufferings of the hero and fear of the worst that may happen to him. The change of fortune should not be from bad to good, but reversely from good to bad. The unhappy ending is the only right ending for it is the most tragic in its effect. A happy ending may please us more, but it will not afford the true tragic pleasure aroused by the pity and fear it follows. Therefore, the events comprising the plots will concern only one man and not more. There are two ways in which the emotions may be aroused – by spectacular and more theatrical effects and by the inner structure of the plot. “For, the plot ought to be so constructed that even without the aid of the eye, he who hears the tale told will thrill with horror and melt to pity at what takes place”.

    Peripeteia

    It is a deed done in blindness defeating its own purpose. Reversal of action or intention.

    Anagnorisis

    It is the recognition or discovery of truth, i.e., the discovery of the false moves taking in ignorance., i.e., change from ignorance to knowledge.

    There are 3 elements in a tragic plot which is titled as ‘Reversal Discovery and Calamity’ by Aristotle.

    • Reversal is a change from one to its opposite.
    • Discovery as the word itself indicates a discovery is a change from ignorance to knowledge and it leads either to love or to hatred between persons destined for good or ill fortune. The discovery of this kind with a reversal will carry with it either pity or fear
    • Suffering or calamity of these three, reversal and discovery are essentially related to the plot and action of the play and so is a calamity. A calamity is an action of a destructive or painful nature such as death openly represented, excessive suffering, wounding and the like.

    Main Parts of a Tragedy

    • Prologue – the whole part of a tragedy that precedes the parode, or the first entry of the chorus.
    • Episode – it is the whole of that part of a tragedy that comes between complete choral songs.
    • The Exode – it is the whole of that part of a tragedy which is not followed by a song of the chorus.
    • Chorus – is divided into parode (the first entry of the chorus) and stasimon which is a choral song

    Kinds of Tragedy

    Four kinds of a tragedy are – complex, suffering, character and spectacular.

    Tragic Hero

    Aristotle says, “good men should not be shown passing from prosperity to misery, for, this does not inspire fear or pity, it merely disgusts us”.

    “Nor should an evil man be shown progressing from misery to prosperity. This is the most untragic of all plots, for, it has none of the requisites of a tragedy; it does not appeal to our humanity or awake in pity or fear in us.”

    “Nor again should an utterly worthless man be seen falling from prosperity to misery. This may not arouse either pity or fear; for, our pity is awakened by undeserved misfortune, and our fear by that of someone just like ourselves – pity for the undeserving sufferer.”

    Ideal tragic hero – “there remains a mean between these two extremes. This is the sort of man who is not conspicuous for virtue and justice, and whose fall into misery is not due to vice and depravity but rather to some error”.

    Hamartia

    According to Aristotle, a tragic hero is one who falls from high state or fame not through the vice or depravity but by some great hamartia. It is an error of judgment.

    An ideal tragedy results from – human error, error on the part of friends and relatives, error on the part of the hero himself and the calamity due to the false move blindly made by a friend or kinsman or by himself.

    Characters of a Tragedy

    First and foremost is that the character should be good. Secondly, the place of portrayal should be appropriate. Thirdly, the characters should be lifelike. Fourthly, they should be consistent. The unraveling of the plot should arise from the circumstances of the plot. The dues ex machina should be used only for matters outside the play proper, either for things that happened before it and that cannot be known by the human characters, or things that are yet to come and that require to be foretold prophetically – for, we allow to the Gods the power to see all things.

    “Since tragedy is a representation of people who are better than the average, they must be presented well… in portraying men who are hot-tempered or phlegmatic or who have other defects of character, must bring out these qualities in them, and at the same time show them as decent people.”

    Different Kinds of Discovery

    The first is the least artistic and is mostly used from sheer lack of invention, this is discovery by means of visible science or tokens. The second class of discoveries is those which are manufactured by the poet and which are inartistic for that reason. The third kind of discovery is due to memory. The fourth kind is the result of reasoning. Of all the forms of discovery, the least is that which is brought about by the incidents themselves, even the startling disclosure results from events that are probable.

    Phallic Songs

    Are sung in honor of Dionysus, the God of fertility. Comedy represents men as worse than they are and ridicule the general vices. They are merely men of ugliness. By calling them worse, which Aristotle means that they are men with, “some defect which is not painful or destructive”. Its main function is to provoke laughter; no personal attacks and no kind of malicious pleasure is involved. It represents what has happened but what may happen.

    Aristotle’s Style of Writing

    He considers two things in the style of writing – clarity, and propriety (a suitable way of writing). The objective of writing is to communicate the meaning and must be intelligible. The same mode of writing cannot be used and for this propriety is important. For, intelligibility, current words can be used for the understanding of the people. In order to gain dignity and be stately, unfamiliar words can be used which will surprise the readers as well as gives a kind of novelty to the person. For poetry – compound words can be used, for an epic – rare and unfamiliar words can be used and for drama – metaphorical language that will be close to the everyday use by the people. A perfect poetic style uses words of all kinds in a judicious combination.

    Defects of Aristotle’s Poetics

    There are certain defects in Aristotle’s Poetics as it is fragmentary in nature. There is no proportionate discussion in it. He places a tragedy above an epic and has ignored the lyrical poetry and descriptive poetry. The effects of comedy and epic have been slightly treated and a larger part of the discussion is devoted to tragedy alone. The style is telegraphic and highly concentrated. There is often the signs of hesitation and uncertainty in the use of terminology. His theories are based exclusively on Greek poetry and drama.

  • Political and Cross-cultural Milieu

    Indian politics has its major roots on the invasion over it by many empires and imperial powers, the slavery under the British for more than two centuries in specific. The entry of East India Company was the root cause of the various political issues in India during the Mughal empire. And it resulted in the demolition of Indian cottage and small scale industries in order to develop the trade, making many Indians rising issues against British.

       Then started the political crises which invoked several writers to write about those political issues. Any political novel must possess both the form and content along with interpretation as to develop many portals as a part of dealing with various discussions and issues, like British colonisation, Partition of India and Pakistan, riots, numerous loss of lives, Opium Wars and slavery to mention a few.

       Starting from the earlier writers like Rabindranath Tagore, Raja Rao, R.K.Narayanan and Mulk Raj Anand, and the post- independence- Khushwanth Singh to the present writers. Manohar Malgonankar, Shashi Taroor and Amitav Ghosh talk about various aspects of political concepts in their novels, dealing with the reality of it.

        Khushwant Singh’s  Train to Pakistan depicts the trauma of  the victims of Partition. Since he belongs to a community who remained the victim of this cruel fate, he could easily  understand the pain of the people who have been prey to such issues.He has also participated as a villager in the events of Mano Majra, an imaginative peaceful abode of communal harmony but he has narrated the whole tragedy as a detached observer. He does not blame either British or any religion for it but regrets for such an evil occurrence that has taken away a lot of lives. He narrates the agony of the colonised people who were traumatised both physically and emotionally.

          Bankin Chandra Chaterje’s first Indian novel paved way for the hit Bollywood patriotic movie Anand Math, from which emerged the National song of India,”Vande Matharam”. In the later stage, came the novels of Rabindranath Tagore whose The Home and the World and The Wreck talk about a family being caught in the political turmoil during the freedom struggle. He gives more prominence to women characters who also had a major role in freedom fight of that period. Manohar Malgonkar in his A Bend in the Ganges creates a new perspective, talking about the Divide and Rule policy of the English thereby leading India to Partition. He depicts the aspects of political reality into the novel which prevented India from developing any further.

          Shashi Tharoor in his novel The Great Indian Novel has adopted the story of the Indian legend Mahabaraha through which he satirises the political condition of the present  era. Though Mahabaratha belongs to early ages, the politics covered in it proves that political issues prevail even from earlier ages.

          Amitav Ghosh in his novel The Shadow Lines has taken the concept of Partition of India and its victims, politics being played upon them and it’s brutality over its own people more than anything else. He does not give more space to the families belonging to each region and country and explains the agony they suffer due to political turmoils, in which even the people who desperately wanted to take part in freedom struggle have lost faith and passion for country. They fail to be patriotic further, as they happened to lose their beloved ones in riots in an unfaithful manner and for invalid reasons and causes. R.K Narayan’s Waiting for Mahatma deals with a distinct aspect of the fall-out of the Partition where it is stressed that ‘making of a country is not as important as that of making  humanity’. When India got its independence, some people were caught in riots, losing their lives and many children were orphaned. Such pressures and agonies forced some writers to deal with the Partition of India in their works.

          These novels can be considered as the factual and unofficial documents recording the plights of people – physically and emotionally, making the novels more than a historical novel. These novelists feel that political issues are responsible for human destruction all across the world. Such an approach is considered objective by the author and the audience in recording the background politics as major themes in their works.

  • Narrative Techniques of Indian English Novels

    Narrtive technique is one among the important aspects of literature. It deals with the facts and imagination as based on the narrator. A narrative is different to that of descriptions in a work’s quality or situations. It consists of a set of events as recounted by the author through the narrator in which the events are selected and arranged in a particular order, like telling a story through a first person narrative and third person narrative.

          A narrative  technique is the method of telling stories which is distinct from that of dramatic and lyrical poetry. To put it short, a narrative is a story which can be conveyed through pictures, poetry, songs and so on in a fiction or any non-fiction. This mode narrating a story is connected to someone in specific and hence becomes a technique used by that person who narrates the story. This narrator serves as a prism through which ideas and views are transmitted to the readers. A narrator has to detain the past, by holding the present and making the reader ready for the future.

          Some techniques since 1930s when Raja Roa’s  when Kanthapura was published. Usually narrative techniques are explained through point of view in a novel, which posseses three types namely- first person narrative, when he comments on the events; the third person narrative in which the narrator is objective and omniscient  point of view where the narrator is God who makes his in bgpresence felt.

    A narrator has plethora of options to narrate the events.It is based on either the temporal or casual way of narrating through ‘focalization’. It changes the course of0 narrative as a reader, receiving impressions of characters through narration. Moreover in an emerging narrative technique, a reader can notice double consciousnesls in the narrator. This is due to the narrator’s speaking language which  is tinged with deep anguish for mymotherland since 1990s in Indian English fiction. Thus there is deep rooted awareness of the belonging to the periphery.

    In this way, R.K.Narayanis a good story teller who shows no interest in socio-political issues or even in following techniques. He values only the story and narrates it in a superficial level and in a deeper sense.His tone of narration gives rise to humour, and the narrative technique of Narayan.

    There are several other writers who use the stream of consciousness technique in narrating stories. Like things one after the another,whereas Khushwanth Singh in his Train to Pakistan gives a blending of growth in space and movement in time. He elegantly describes the movement of trains, signaling time for action, symbol of despair and darkness. His symbol of narrative is suggestive of the upcoming events of the novel.

  • Themes and Motifs of Indian English Fiction

    Most Indian English fictions written in the post-independence period are different from the earlier English writings that dealt mostly with social reform issues, in contrast to the present ones that deal with issues of relatively peripheral nature. The difference is clearly visible through the issues they take up based on the present discourses. 

    The three famous writers – R K Narayanan, Mulk Raj Anand and Raja Rao, belonged to the post-independence period who were known to have dealt with issues that prevailed during their age, like the issues of freedom, struggle, and the social and political problems of the then India. Novels published during this timeframe (1935 to 1960) delineate the experience of the colonial age and dilemmas of post-independent reality. When these issues were well known to readers, the harshness of colonial activities and postcolonial India were also predominant in writing fiction. Mulk Raj Anand has focused on the untouchable mentality of the colonisers that prevailed them in his works like Untouchable and Coolie.

    Next comes the modern generation writers like Salman Rushdie, Amitav Ghosh, Shashi Tharoor, Vikram Seth, etc, transcending the then existing writing to create new patterns and traditions. They show case the past in the present era thereby emphasising on the affected lives of people and about the sensitive issues that have been ignored for various reasons. R.K.Narayanan has focused on the South Indian middle class in his fictions, by being aloof from his contemporary socio-political issues. Though he did not deal with socio political issues, his novels written after independence were much notable. His fictions resemble more of caricature rather than characters.

    Raja Rao was considered as a new star shining bright, though he was the youngest of the trio. His Kandhapura represents the Gandhian principles and ideologies of non-violence and abolition of untouchability. He has also written a metaphysical comedy named, The Cat and the Shakespeare. The Bengali writer of that time Bhabani Bhattacharya dealt with cultural and political themes in his works. His major work So Many Hungers! deals with various types of hungers that dwell in people’s life – hunger for food, money, sex, and power. His other works like Music of Mohini also deals with socio political issues with a harsh reality.  

    Many writers of the present trend have also involved in writing about migration and displacement, which is named the Diasporic studies. Jhumpa Lahiri, Anita Desai, Bharathi Mukherjee, Amitav Ghosh and so on deal with this type of themes and issues by exhibiting the sufferings faced by the displaced people who belong to nowhere. Though it is generally called diasporic studies, it has several variations in it like temporal and special aspects, hybridity and so on. 

    They talk about the people who immigrate into a country carrying only the memories of their motherland which M.G.Vasanji ironically  calls as “Gunny sack”. Moreover, the recent writers also talk of various other themes like postcolonialism, postmodernity and also about reinventing history, which has neglected and erased the sacrifices made by the common and the ordinary people; bringing them back by dwelling into the minds of these imaginary characters with real pain. They deal with the protagonists opposite the great figures of history.

    They question the certainties of the past by looking into the private lives of ordinary people. The postcolonial literature focuses on historical issues what Rushdie calls as ‘weightlessness’. They also exhibit the experience of cultural transplantation thereby developing various new perspectives and possibilities. Several of these writers are settled in the West. Their motive is to recreate the contemporary social milieu and cultural crisis in their native land and attempt to redefine it in the emerging postcolonial context. They intend to mix the past with the present and future. And, about the cultural diversities that prevailed or prevail in Indian fiction. Their themes and motifs are hence to explore various areas like political domination by the foreign forces, the invasion of West upon the East, cultural fragmentation and slavery over the natives by following the footsteps of their colonisers.

  • The Historical Depth and Migration in Amitav Ghosh’s Novels

    The Historical Depth and Migration in Amitav Ghosh’s Novels

    Amitav Ghosh (1956 – ), a versatile writer, is renowned for his complicated writings. His language is exuberant and rich. He constructs complex narratives, enormous research, and provides vivid descriptions. Ghosh is an expert in dealing with space and time. All his novels are rooted in strong historical backgrounds. The individuals of Ghosh are migrants by various perspectives based on the stands they take. His novels project various historical events like the Partition of the India in 1947, violence, riots, colonial rule, and national movement for freedom, patriotic sentiments, and impacts of such historical causes like people‘s conflicts, dislocations, displacements and migration for numerous reasons.

    Ghosh‘s novels revolve around the common people rather than important people or any historical figures. He interprets history through the eyes of the ordinary people. All such aspects bring way to argue his novels to various interpretations of theories like postcolonial theory, postmodernist theory, and people‘s inner conflicts that lead to Psychoanalytical theory and New Historicism to name a few. Though there are many arguments that his works focus mainly on postcolonial aspects, he seems to reject the opinion which is evident when he rejected the Commonwealth Award for his 2001 novel, The Glass Palace. Ghosh himself being accustomed to travel during his childhood has used several of his travel experiences in his novels. Being born to an educated family on 11 July 1956 in Kolkatta, Ghosh has been fortunate enough to have studied in various best educational institutions within the country and outside as well; since his father was a Lieutenant Colonel he was on the move constantly.

    He was educated at the Doon School, Dehradun, did his B.A (History) in St.Stephen‘s College, Delhi University and M.A (Sociology) from Delhi University and was awarded his Doctorate (Anthropology) in St. Edmund Hall, Oxford. His first job was at The Indian Express newspaper in New Delhi. Though he was a voracious reader from his childhood, he realised his passion for writing only after his graduation. Working in a newspaper as a journalist had made him contribute a lot in his career of writing. He has pointed his interest in an interview with Kavitha Chibber, “When you do that kind of close up journalism in India it shows a lot of what society is like. You get to see massive corruption and all the bad stuff very close up. But I soon realized that in the long run, journalism in India and racking 1000 words at the end of each day was not what I was looking for.” (kavithachibber.com)

    All his novels come out of the amount of his research and extensive travel to the places that he writes about. His work depicts his vast knowledge from history to sociology to anthropology, through which he attaches himself closer to history and to engage himself in the study of mankind to develop his real life characters that create greater significance in the field of writing and as a man‘s anxiety to relate himself to other man, his country and to its history and society. Thus, as a novelist, during his interview with Michelle Caswell he opines, “For me, the value of the novel as a form is that it is able to incorporate elements of every aspect of life-history, natural history, rhetoric, politics, beliefs, religion, family, love, sexuality. As I see it, the novel is a meta-form that transcends the boundaries that circumscribe other kinds of writing, rendering meaningless the usual workaday distinctions between historian, journalist, anthropologist etc.” (asiasociety.org)

     Ghosh‘s  works consists  of  fictions  and non-fictions  that include travelogues  and essays.  His  first novel  The Circle of Reason  was  published in 1986 which won the Prix Medicis  Estranger  Award in 1990. The novel consists  of  three segments  –  the protagonists, relation with the people  met  and the  places  he visited. The  three  segments 25 are namely, Sattra, Rajas  and Tamas, centring on the protagonist Alu  (Nachiketa  Bose) who experiences  multiple migrations  from  Bengal to Kolkatta, Al  Ghazira and Algeria, until he returns home.

    His  second novel The Shadow Lines (1988) which won the Sahithya Akademi Award and the Puraskar focuses  around the Partition of  India and Pakistan, interweaving memory, history  and  fiction, depicting the impacts  of  violence  and riots  on the lives  of  the ordinary  people leaving  back pathetic  and traumatic memories  of  displacement and dislocation to them. The  unnamed narrator takes  the readers  along with  his  wavering memories  with unreciprocated love,  failed  marriage, friendship, distorted freedom, painful  memories  and  migration with the background of  history  through  the riots  that affect the  family  or  an individual. 

    In an Antique Land (1992)  portrays  the travel experiences  of  Ghosh during his PhD research  work in Egypt. The novel is  the representation of  his  taking notes  of  all that he saw,  about the people he  met and the places  he visited. The  story  revolves  around a slave named Bomma and the trade  between India and Egypt and also about the experiences  of  Ghosh in  Egypt. The novel  covers  the experiences  of  migration by  the historical as  well as  fictional characters  as  they  were forced  to leave  their  lands  to  migrate to another land in  search of  employment.  

    In  The Calcutta Chromosome  (1996), Ghosh revisits the  history  of  the discovery of  the  Malaria Vector  that unravels  the  contributions  made  by the Indian  researchers  who were generally  degraded by  the Europeans.  Ghosh connects  the events  of  the present and the past with the possibility  of  finding immortality  in the  future.  He brings  in the real essence into the novel through the  historical event of  medical science,  where he also probes  into the importance  of  women in the  society  and about their contributions that went  mostly  unnoticed.  Such a novel  mixed with science, fiction and  fantasy  has  won  the Arthur  C. Clarke Prize  for  Science  Fiction in 1997.                        

    The Glass  Palace  (2000)  is  a novel that unfolds  the political turmoil that  prevailed in India, Burma and  Malaya, affecting the people. The story  revolves  around these three countries  that run up to three  generations  from  the  nineteenth  century  through the late twentieth century. The story  begins  with the  exile of  the  Burmese King and Queen who move  along to  Ratnagiri, India, as  an  exile. The  incident follows  with the lives  of  an Indian orphan Rajkumar in Burma, the Queen’s  maid  Dolly  and the  other  prominent roles around them. The novel  portrays  several historical themes  like independence, colonial rule, the  World  War and  the impacts  they  create  on the lives  of  the  people in these countries.

    This  novel won the 2001 Frankfurt International E-Book Award for  Fiction and the Commonwealth  Writers Prize for  Fiction  which he declined.  When  asked about it in an interview by  Kavitha  Chibber, about his  being passionately  anti-colonial and withdrawing the novel  because of  his  sentiment,  he replies: “I  can‘t give  any  particular reason why  there is  so much written about  my being anti-colonial. Perhaps  it is  because of  the  Commonwealth Prize issue. It‘s  not that I  have a  very  intensely  negative  feeling towards colonialism. It is  an undeniable part of  our  past that we  should  either be complacent about or  be glorifying. For  me, as  an Indian  writer, this  Commonwealth demarcation is  totally  unacceptable.  What do  we for  example, have in common with writers  from  New Zealand?  It‘s  just a stupid thing and unless someone  stands  up and  does  something about it,  this will go on.” (kavithachibber.com)  

    His  next novel  The Hungry Tide  (2004)  has  the  historical backdrop of  the Morichjanpi  massacre of  1978-79, where the Government  of  West  Bengal evacuated thousands  of  Bengali refugees  from  the island nearby  Sundarbans. It has  an eco-critical touch all through the  story  that revolves  around the three characters whose worlds  are different,  yet connected  at one point, dealing with their  own inner conflicts  and interests with each other. The novel has  won him  the Hutch Crossword Book Award in 2005. All his  works require  a lot of  research that  extends  up to five  years  for  The  Glass  Palace (2000)  and so on. He has  visited Sundarbans  for  this purpose  and has  met a few researchers  related to cytology  for  his  book, where he  has  created an imaginary  place  to take his  plot  accordingly, relating the readers to  the labyrinth of  the  magical and the real. 

    Ghosh’s  Dancing in  Cambodia:  At Large  in Burma  (1998)  is  a travelogue, where he studied life, culture,  art and social  and political institutions  of  the places  that he visited. He brings in the parts of  the once  colonised nations – Cambodia and  Burma.  The Imam and the Indian  (2002), is  a non-fiction which is  a collection of  eighteen  prose pieces written over twenty  years. 

     Sea of Poppies  (2008)  is  the  first of  his  Ibis  Trilogy  that  brings in the lives  of  various  characters,  some who  were exploited by  British colonisation and some by  their  own society  and  kith and kin. The  novel  mainly  focuses  on  the lives  of  the indentured labourers who are transported to the  plantations  of  the  British and also especially about the opium  trade  and addiction.  Opium  war plays  the background of  the novel that  moves  around India, Britain and  China. The characters  in the  novel, irrespective of  their  nationality, religion  and ranks, are united in the ship  that takes  them to Mauritius  which is  equally  dangerous  and tumultuous, looking at themselves  as  kiths and kin, who have recently  been washed away  from  their  family  ties. The novel was  short listed for  the Man Booker Prize of  2008  and a  co-winner of  the Vodafone Crossword Book Award 2009.  

     River  of Smoke  (2011)  is  the second volume of  the  Ibis  trilogy. The novel follows the incidents  on the  ship  Ibis, in the  Sea of Poppies  (2008)  as  a continuation of  the  story, though it can be read without reading the  first volume  as  Ghosh  considers  it to be. It showcases  the lives  of  the Indian  migrants  and  other migrants  in Mauritius  and also traces the lives  and fates  of  other characters  that  are struck in the Opium  trade  that led to the first Opium  War. The novel was  short listed for  South Asian  Literature.  NPR  (National Public Radio, US)  announced the book  as  one of  the  year‘s  historical novels.   Flood of Fire  (2015)  is  the final book in the  Ibis  trilogy  which  portrays  Kesri Singh, the brother  of  Deeti, Zachary  Reid,  as  a  man of  ambition to become like his employer Mr. Burnham,  Mrs. Burnham, an unexpected  major role, Captain Mee,  Neel and others  either to be reunited or to face  their  destiny  as  called  for. 

    The  Great Derangement  (2016)  is the most recent nonfiction work that deals with climate change. All his works have different forms of narrative techniques, like the first-person narrative in  The Shadow  Lines, with the narrator left unnamed; the use of third-person narration in a few novels, and using the first-person narrative as himself in  In  an Antique Land.  The  Ibis trilogy focuses mainly on language  –  creoles  spoken by  the lascars, shipmates, indentured labourers and even the Europeans  to their  servants. He is  well known for  his  descriptive narration of  the  sea, land, or  any place or an  object or even describing nature  and its  beauty  for  that  matter.  His  sense  of  space and time has  been a prominent aspect to notice  in all his  works,  The  Shadow  Lines  in specific. He  also  makes use of  several Indian  mythologies  in  The  Calcutta Chromosome, The Hungry Tide  and Indian Upanishads  in  The Circle of Reason, naming the three  chapters accordingly,  and depicts  the  view that nothing can be  considered  ‘home’  due to migration and alienation caused  by  man‘s  crisis  for  existence.

    More importantly  from  the works  of  Ghosh, it is  obvious  that he uses  history  in all his  works  as  a thread that develops  the plots  and also about the  migration of  people on various conditions. His  works include  lots  of  history, research  and travel that he also gained from  his  personal  experiences  that give him  a broad  and deep insight into his  plots and characters. His  study  of  sociology, anthropology  and journalistic  experiences, have moulded his  characters  in their  lives  and  also in  the study  of  people and  their  families. All his  novels  deal with the  lives  of  the ordinary  people and their  struggles  to hold onto their lives. All these require a  vast study  and knowledge of  the  places  and the  detailing to shed on the roles  they  play  that deal with historical truth and knowledge in abundance  to achieve what he has  aspired to. His  books  are works  of  excellence  and intelligence  and knowledge  about the past history,  migration and  fiction writings.  

    Ghosh does  not only  narrate the  stories  of  the past but he also  focuses  on migration  and displacement. For  Ghosh,  migrants  are  mostly victims  of  history; various historical events  that had happened  and which had ended up in  exploiting and destroying or  reshaping the lives  of  the people  politically and economically  displaced. Some are displaced  from  their  motherland and some are bound to migrate due  to a  push‘  factor  that either captures  their intentions  or  attracts  them  to their  land of  immigration as  voluntary migrants  or  due to a pull  factor  that  forces  them  to a voluntary  migration.  This  being one of  the perspectives, the  other one deals  with the  forced  migration which  is  characterised by  the  characters‘  reluctance to return to the native land and the  nostalgia and  yearning to return as  well, that leads  to displacement on the  whole. Migration is  seen in such different perspectives, depicting its  various dimensions  as  viewed by  Ghosh.

    Equal prominence  is  given to the discussion of  the impact of  geographical displacement on  families  as  to that of  history  of  a land. The plots depict  the displacement of  nation as  a  whole alongside a  more deep purveyance  of  the  families  ripped apart owing to forced  migration that in turn end up reviving the old ties  in new  families  that they  make while on their journey  of  migration. Thus  Ghosh depicts  the other side  of  diaspora, the positive side of  migration as  a  “self-invention”  (dnaindia.com),  and  a  regenerative process of  identifying oneself  in  a few  of  his  plots. Ghosh’s  delineation of  characters  thus  point to the two sided aspect of  a familial bond.  

    Sources:

    amitavghosh.com

    Amitav Ghosh by Anushman A. Mondal

    Amitav Ghosh by John C Hawley

    Kavithachibber.com

    dnaindia.com

    Amitav Ghosh b Shubha Tiwari

  • Growth of the Indian Novels in English

    Growth of the Indian Novels in English

    Indian writing in English is a broad outcome of the English Education system that prevailed in India during British colonisation. It is widespread in recent years and has been recognised as a part of  “Commonwealth Literature” which possesses the writings of  British colonised countries. Until recently, this attitude has taken a turn and has also claimed a higher position in itself as Indian English Literature, thus contributing a great significance in the World Literature.

        A number of Indian writers contribute their writings in English to the modern world. The pioneers of this contribution are Raja Ram Mohan Roy and Lord Macaulay, who were inspirational in sowing the writings across the country. Among all the genres, fiction being the most powerful weapon has acquired greater significance in the present era. The country’s writing, mainly fiction has reached the developed countries like Europe and America who admire and appreciate the works of Indian writers.

         The first Indian English novel was written by Bankim Chandra Chatterjee, RajMohan’s Wife (1864) which paved way to several other fictions. The novels written during the 1860s were mostly based on social and historical issues which were basically modelled on the British writers like Daniel Defoe and Sir Walter Scott. To mention some of the novels between 1860 and 1900 are Ramakrishna Punt’s The Bay of Bengal, Anand Prasad Dutt’s The Indolence and Trailokya Das Hirimba’s Wedding.

       Later arrived the twentieth century novels that paved way for translation of their own works or even other’s works. Romesh Chandra Dutt translated his own Bengali novels one among which appears to be a first realistic novel that aimed at social reform, supporting widow marriage. A few other writers to mention are S.T.Ram The Cosmopolitan  Hindustani, B.K.Sarkar’s Man of Letters and T,K.Gopal Pannikar’s Storm and Sunshine.

      The next stage was influenced by Gandhian views and principles that grew across the country creating a great impact on patriotism . His principles affected not only the political field of India but also on every walk of life. It created a sudden change on the writings but turned their attention towards the contemporary issues from that of the past. Various political issues and problems were taken into account and were brought out to the people of India by the eminent writers through their writings. The major themes that were dealt by them were struggle for freedom, fight between the East and West, pathetic situations of the untouchables, the poor farmers and their exploited lands and so on. 

         Such impact of the Gandhian perceptions can be seen in the works of K.S. Vengatramani’s Murugan, The Tiller. Followed by these writers came the trinity writers as K R Srinivasa Iyengar calls them, –Raja Rao, Mulk Raj Anand and R.K.Narayanan whose emergence created an enormous impact in the field of writing, especially, fiction. They propogated the writing of Indo English fiction, the earlier named Indian writing in English, followed by another prominent contemporary of theirs, Bhabani Bhattacharya, whose novels also dealt with people’s sufferings.

        Their creations were a pathway to writing fictions, through which Indian writing in English achieved a remarkable position in the history of world literature. They also brought in Indo-Anglian novels into existence which gave them distinctiveness that laid a stone on content and form in writing. This has led to the recent writings of the present era of the twenty first century writers.

      The period from 1980s witnessed a second period of the Indian novel in English through the writing of Salman Rushdie’s  Midnight’s Children. Its impact has been seen in numerous ways by various critics and novelists. The inclusion of Bollywood references sexual utterances, allergory, touch upon history and the use of language have made the work a landmark of this period. It has reached out to international audiences by creating its own identity on Indian English Literature.

         Along with him are several other writers who call themselves Stephenians as they studied in St.Stephens college, Delhi who are Allan Sealy, Amitav Ghosh, Shashi Tharoor  and Upamanyu Chatterjee. They seem to acknowledge each other’s influence in their works. Their flow of imagination on the untouched facts has given prominence for the books to be published in International publications like Penguin, Harpercollins,etc.

         Authors of 1980s like Upamanyu Chatterjee tried to blend in the ‘Indianness’ as a mixture of culture to touch upon various aspects of languages that are being used to bring out various concepts and stories like his English August. Some other novelists have tried to create an awareness regarding the earlier prevailed inequality of access to the language English and its problems of communication between various classes and culture prevailing within India . They try to explore the conflict between tradition and the modernity in contemporary India.

        As stated in Contemporary Indian Writers, ‘such variations are seen in many writers like Rushdie, who considers Bombay to be a place where many cultures meet and finds it a supplementary is seen in contrast as a place which possesses  a sense of disorienting loss’ by Amit Chaudhuri. In the same era comes Amitav Ghosh, who took the same turn as that of Rushdie through his works. Ghosh was the first Stephanian who gave an immediate response to the challenge of Midnight’s Children. His first novel The Circle of Reason is written almost in Rushdie’s work of magical realism.

        All his works are almost reinvention of history and about the lives of the unnoticed ordinary people, nationalistic, colonisation, migration and colonial hegemony.  Several novelists have followed Ghosh in creating historical narratives and have succeeded in doing so. Another similar idea of converting or using one of the greatest Indian legends for the purpose of historical narration is Shashi Tharoor’s The Great Indian Novel which adapts the story of the great legend Mahabaratha as an allergy of modern Indian history.

        Hence if all these writers share a common interest in retrieving history, suppressed histories, they do it in their own ways and act of narration. This process of excluding the country as a national imaginary has brought about a great change into looking at history. This making of history which itself acts as a form of narrative relies on these literary devices to create and predict its own meaning.

  • A Short Introduction to Literary Criticism

    A critic is an ideal reader, methodically trained and provides judgement. A critic analyses, classifies,evaluates, examines, inquires, subjects the text closer, scrutinises, pronounces a verdict upon the text. He demands intellectual freedom. Literary criticism is an exercise of judgement on the works of literature.

    History of Criticism

    Hellenic Criticism

    Fourth and fifth century Athens became the centre of criticism, mainly Plato and his disciple Aristotle. Many real principles were derived from them. Aristotle was the first theorist in literature and the first scientific critic whose poetry is known famously as the storehouse of theories.

    Hellenistic Criticism 

    Scholars of this period preserved the writings of the writers. Alexandria became the literary activity of this age.

    Greco-Roman Criticism

    They were inspired by the ancient Greek writers and wanted to be either equal or to excel them. So they started imitating them. They elaborated, interpreted and started applying the rules of the ancient people in their variety of writing. Horace, Quintilian, Longinus are the notable critics of this period

    The Dark Middle Ages

    Fifth to fifteenth century which was filled with confusions and dislocation and hence the literary activities suffered. Hair splitting arguments took place and were called hair splitters. they started frowning at literature as if it were sensual. Grammar, rhetoric and logic were given a pride of place during this period. It also integrated the ancient literature in an allegoric manner. The only ray of hope of this period was Dante. 

    The Renaissance Criticism 

    Great ancient Greek books were translated in this age. Appreciation and creation went hand in hand. Creativity of great amount took place. There are four stages – rennaisance of style and language of the ancients rhetorations, made an attempt to introduce classical metres into English poetry, an attempt was made to justify imaginative literature against the attacks of puritans and moralists, and attempts were made to device rules and principles to guide the would-be future poets. 

    Neoclassical Criticism 

    Ben Johnson was an important critic of this age who was also the first champion of new classical criticism. he followed the liberal criticism aiming at curbing the absurdities of literature. Addison, Steele Dryden wanted to bring back classical rules once more into this age and called themselves neoclassicals and followed strict rules.

    The Romantic Phase

    French Revolution and German idealist philosophy contributed to the development of race of romanticism individuality subjectivity freedom of expression and inspiration were given importance what’s that and called which were important products of this time imagination and creativity well given room 

    Victorian Criticism

    This phase saw a transition of the writers focusing on art, literature and providing critical comments on other works. This period of ocused significantly on an ideal life. Great writers of poetry, prose like Tennyson, Dickens, Arnold and others hold the pride of embracing this Victorian literature

    Modern Age

    People in this phase were not original thinkers but academicians. They formulated theories and started discussing them in classes. It starts with T S Eliot and the rise of other new critics. The study of the text has to be done word by word, sentence by sentence as they believed. F R Leavis was also a notable textual scholar of this period.

    Three forms of Criticism

    Legislative Criticism

    This form of critical endeavour lays down rules for the art of writing. It’s largely based on standard works of literature like Greek and Latin literature. It assumes that the would-be writer has only to be told how to write well. Hence it addresses the writer and not the reader. 

    Aesthetic Criticism

    It treats literature as art and as an independent activity of the mind, having an end of its own which may or may not coincide with that of religion, morality, science or politics. It therefore probes the nature of literary arts and formulates its theories accordingly.

    Descriptive Criticism

    It is a study of individual words of authors’  methods, aims and effects. It may draw on legislative or aesthetic norms to justify its actions or follow an independent life of its own, it assures that what it says can always be confirmed from the work under discussion.