Category: Literature

  • Political Complexities and Social Hierarchies: Recurring Themes in Chaucer’s Works

    Geoffrey Chaucer, an English poet, civil servant, and writer, is still regarded as the father of English Literature. His significant works, The Book of the Duchess (c. 1368), The House of Fame (c. 1379), Troilus and Criseyde (c. 1380s), and The Canterbury Tales (c. 1387–1400), reflect the complexities of his era through recurring themes. These poems with such themes blend medieval traditions with proto-humanist perspectives, influenced by his exposure to French, Italian, and classical literature.

    Social Hierarchy and Mobility

    Chaucer’s England was rigidly stratified, yet the Black Death and economic shifts created opportunities for social mobility. The Canterbury Tales captures this through its diverse cast of pilgrims, from the noble Knight to the coarse Miller.

    Example: “The Wife of Bath”, a wealthy cloth-maker, challenges gender and class norms, boasting of her economic independence and sexual agency. Her tale critiques patriarchal marriage while reflecting the rising influence of the merchant class.

    Significance: Chaucer’s inclusion of lower-class voices, like the Miller or the Reeve, alongside nobles, mirrors the social tensions of his time, where traditional hierarchies were questioned.

    Courtly Love and Chivalry

    Influenced by French romance traditions and the chivalric ideals of the Hundred Years’ War, Chaucer explores courtly love in works like Troilus and Criseyde and “The Knight’s Tale”.

    Example: In Troilus and Criseyde, the Trojan prince Troilus’s idealised love for Criseyde is tested by betrayal and war, blending romance with philosophical reflections on fate and free will, inspired by Boccaccio’s poem Il Filostrato.

    Significance: Chaucer often subverts chivalric ideals with irony, as in “The Knight’s Tale”, where noble love leads to rivalry and tragedy, reflecting the era’s complex views on honour and warfare.

    Satire and Critique of Corruption

    Chaucer’s works frequently satirise institutional corruption, particularly within the Church, which was criticised for greed and hypocrisy during the late 14th century.

    Example: In The Canterbury Tales, “the Pardoner” and “the Summoner” embody ecclesiastical abuse, selling fake relics or exploiting their authority for profit. “The Pardoner’s Tale”, a moral story about greed, is ironic given his own avarice.

    Significance: This reflects the growing anticlerical sentiment of the time, influenced by figures like John Wycliffe, whose Lollard movement criticised Church wealth and corruption.

    Humanism and Individuality

    Chaucer’s exposure to Italian writers, such as Dante, Petrarch, and Boccaccio, during his 1372–1373 travels introduced him to early humanist ideas, emphasising individual experience and reason.

    Example: Characters like “the Wife of Bath” or “the Merchant” in The Canterbury Tales are vividly individualised, with distinct voices and motivations, unlike the allegorical figures familiar in medieval literature.

    Significance: This proto-humanist focus on human complexity anticipates Renaissance literature, distinguishing Chaucer from his contemporaries.

    Language and Vernacular Identity

    Chaucer’s use of Middle English, rather than Latin or French, was revolutionary. English was considered a “vulgar” language, but Chaucer’s polished verse elevated its literary status.

    Example: The Canterbury Tales employs varied linguistic registers, from the elevated style of “he Knight to the bawdy colloquialisms of the Miller, reflecting England’s linguistic diversity.

    Significance: By writing in Middle English, Chaucer helped standardise the language, contributing to a national literary identity during a time when French still dominated courtly literature.

    Fortune and Fate

    The medieval concept of Fortune’s Wheel, where human fortunes rise and fall unpredictably, is reflected in Chaucer’s works, which reflect the era’s uncertainty amid plague, war, and political upheaval.

    Example: In Troilus and Criseyde, the lovers’ fates are shaped by war and betrayal, with Chaucer invoking the goddess Fortune to underscore life’s unpredictability.

    Significance: This theme resonates with the era’s philosophical debates, influenced by the Roman philosopher Boethius’s philosophical work On the Consolation of Philosophy, which Chaucer translated as Boece.


    To Sum Up

    The “Age of Chaucer” represents a pivotal moment in English history, where social, political, and cultural shifts laid the groundwork for the early modern era. By writing in Middle English and creating psychologically complex characters, Chaucer bridged medieval and Renaissance traditions, earning him the title “father of English literature.” His works reflect the era’s tensions, including class struggles, religious critique, and the interplay of chivalry and pragmatism, while offering timeless insights into human nature. Chaucer’s influence on the English language and literature endures, with The Canterbury Tales remaining a cornerstone of Western literature for its vivid portrayal of medieval society and its universal themes.

  • Impacts of the Historical Period during the Age of Chaucer

    Impacts of the Historical Period during the Age of Chaucer

    Chaucer’s Lifespan (c. 1343–1400)

    Geoffrey Chaucer was born around 1343 in London, likely in the bustling commercial area near the Thames where his father, John Chaucer, worked as a prosperous vintner. The exact date of his birth is uncertain, as medieval records rarely noted such details for non-nobles. Still, evidence from court documents, such as a 1386 testimony where he described himself as “forty years old and more,” supports the 1343 estimate. He died on October 25, 1400, at approximately 57 years old, a notable age given the era’s high mortality rates from disease and poor sanitation. His burial in Westminster Abbey marked his significance, initiating what later became Poets’ Corner.

    The Historical Period: The Late 14th Century

    The “Age of Chaucer” refers to the late 14th century (roughly 1340–1400), a period of significant upheaval and transformation in England. This era sat at the cusp of the High Middle Ages and the early Renaissance, characterised by a period of profound change, and specific historical details illuminating how his environment shaped Chaucer’s life and works.

    The Black Death and Its Aftermath

    Impact: The plague’s devastation reduced England’s population significantly, leading to labour shortages and wage inflation.

    Social Consequences: The resulting social mobility challenged feudal structures, as peasants demanded higher wages. The Peasants’ Revolt of 1381, sparked by a poll tax, reflected these tensions, with rebels burning court records and executing officials in London. Chaucer, as a court official, would have been acutely aware of these events, and his inclusion of lower-class characters in “The Canterbury Tales” reflects this shifting social landscape.

    The Hundred Years’ War

    Military Context: The war with France, driven by Edward III’s claim to the French throne, shaped England’s economy and culture. Chaucer’s capture in 1359 and subsequent ransom highlight his personal connection to the conflict.

    Cultural Influence: The war popularised chivalric ideals, reflected in “The Knight’s Tale”, but Chaucer often critiques these ideals through irony, highlighting their impracticality in a changing world.

    Religious Tensions

    Church’s Corruption: The Catholic Church faced criticism for its wealth and moral failings, exacerbated by the Great Schism (1378–1417), when rival popes claimed authority. John Wycliffe’s Lollard movement, advocating Church reform, gained traction in England, influencing Chaucer’s satirical portrayals of corrupt clergy like “the Pardoner”.

    Chaucer’s Perspective: While not overtly Lollard, Chaucer’s works critique ecclesiastical greed, aligning with broader societal discontent.

    Cultural and Intellectual Shifts

    Italian Influence: Chaucer’s diplomatic missions to Italy introduced him to Dante, Petrarch, and Boccaccio, whose works inspired the narrative complexity of “The Canterbury Tales” and “Troilus and Criseyde”.

    Rise of English: The use of Middle English in literature was a bold choice, as French and Latin dominated elite culture. Chaucer’s polished verse, particularly the iambic pentameter of “The Canterbury Tales”, helped establish English as a literary language.

    Urbanisation and Commerce

    London’s Growth: London was a thriving commercial centre, with a population of 40,000–50,000. Chaucer’s roles in customs and public works reflect the growing importance of trade and infrastructure.

    Merchant Class: His family’s mercantile background and his own career highlight the rising influence of the middle class; a theme explored in characters like the Merchant and the Franklin in “The Canterbury Tales”.

  • Keeping Stories Alive: The Enduring Power of Characters and Literary Works

    Keeping Stories Alive: The Enduring Power of Characters and Literary Works

    The statement “The stories and characters of literary works are alive as long as the works exist” captures a profound truth about the enduring nature of literature, art, and storytelling. Still, it also invites nuance upon closer examination. The statement can be explored to such an extent as to whether it’s true or limited, considering various dimensions such as cultural impact, reinterpretation, and the material and conceptual existence of works.

    Why is the Statement Largely True

    1. **Immortality Through the Work Itself**  

       Stories and characters of all literary works by any author are embedded in the works that contain them—whether in books, films, oral traditions, or other media. As long as these works exist in some form (physical or digital), the characters and narratives they depict remain accessible. For example, characters like Sherlock Holmes, created by Arthur Conan Doyle, or Hamlet, from Shakespeare’s play, continue to “live” because their stories are preserved in texts that are read, performed, and studied centuries later. The physical or digital existence of a book, movie, or recording ensures that new generations can experience the characters and their stories.

    2. **Cultural Resonance and Collective Memory**  

       Beyond the mere existence of a work, stories and characters remain “alive” through their impact on culture and collective consciousness. Iconic characters like Harry Potter or Darth Vader transcend their original works, becoming symbols, archetypes, or reference points in everyday life. For instance, the phrase “May the Force be with you” from *Star Wars* is a cultural touchstone, keeping the story alive in conversations, memes, and popular culture even when the original films are not being watched. If people use them in reference, quote, or draw inspiration from these characters, they maintain a kind of vitality.

    3. **Adaptations and Reinterpretations**  

       Stories and characters often gain new life through adaptations, retellings, or fan-created works. For example, Jane Austen’s *Pride and Prejudice* has been adapted into countless films, TV series, and books, each reintroducing Elizabeth Bennet and Mr Darcy to new audiences. Fan fiction, such as that found on platforms like “Archive of Our Own”, keeps characters alive by placing them in new contexts, ensuring their relevance long after the original work’s creation. This ongoing engagement suggests that characters remain dynamic as long as their stories are reimagined.

    4. **Philosophical Perspective: The Eternal Present of Art**  

       From a philosophical standpoint, art exists in an eternal present. When a person reads “The Odyssey”, his struggles feel immediate, regardless of the thousands of years that separate the reader from the story’s origin. The emotional and intellectual resonance of a character or story does not diminish if the work is accessible, making the characters feel “alive” in the moment of engagement.

    Why the Statement Might Be Considered Limited

    1. **Dependence on Accessibility**  

       While the statement assumes the works will always exist, this is not guaranteed. Physical books can be destroyed, digital files can be lost, and oral traditions can fade if not passed down. For instance, many ancient texts, such as those lost in the burning of the Library of Alexandria, are gone forever, and so with them, their stories and characters. If a work ceases to exist in any tangible form, its characters cannot be said to remain alive in a practical sense.

    2. **Cultural and Contextual Relevance**  

       A story or character’s “life” often depends on their relevance to an audience. Some works, while still existing, fall into obscurity because they no longer resonate with modern values or contexts. For example, certain 19th-century novels with outdated or problematic themes may exist in archives but are rarely read or discussed, rendering their characters effectively “dormant” rather than alive. A character like Hester Prynne from The Scarlet Letter may feel less vivid to modern audiences than more contemporary figures unless actively taught or adapted.

    3. **Interpretation and Evolution**  

       The “life” of a character changes or is distorted over time. As stories are retold or adapted, characters may evolve in ways that diverge from their original forms. For instance, the Dracula of Bram Stoker’s novel is a complex, menacing figure, but in some modern adaptations, he’s a romanticised antihero. If reinterpretations overshadow the original work, one might argue the original character is no longer “alive” in its intended form.

    4. **Subjectivity of the Word “Alive” **  

       The idea of a character being “alive” is subjective. A character exists only in the imagination of the audience, activated through engagement with the work. If no one reads, watches, or remembers a story, the characters may exist in a technical sense (within the work), but they lack vitality without an audience to bring them to life. For example, countless stories from lesser-known authors sit untouched in libraries and unnoticed in various online publishing platforms like Amazon and Google —do their characters feel “alive” without readers?

    Balancing the Perspectives

    The statement is mainly true in the sense that the existence of a work provides the potential for its stories and characters to remain alive. If the work is preserved and accessible, it can be experienced, reinterpreted, or rediscovered, keeping its characters vibrant and alive. However, the statement assumes a degree of permanence and engagement that isn’t always guaranteed. Works can be lost, forgotten, or rendered irrelevant, and the “aliveness” of characters often depends on active cultural or individual engagement.

     Implications for Readers and Visitors Online

    For readers and visitors online, this discussion highlights the power and fragility of storytelling. It encourages us to engage with stories—whether through reading, watching, or creating—to keep them alive and relevant. Platforms like X, where fans discuss, meme, and reinterpret characters, play a crucial role in sustaining their vitality. Considerably, online communities can revive obscure works, giving new life to forgotten characters.

    However, it is also a reminder to actively preserve and share stories. Supporting libraries, digital archives, and open-access platforms ensures that works remain available for future generations. Creating fan content, teaching classic texts, or adapting old stories into abridged and modern formats are all ways to keep the characters breathing in the cultural consciousness.

    Conclusion

    The statement is predominantly true: stories and characters remain alive as long as their works exist, sustained by their accessibility, cultural impact, and reinterpretation. However, their vitality is not automatic—it depends on preservation, engagement, and relevance. This underscores the importance of actively participating in the life of stories, whether by reading, sharing, or reimagining them, whether in physical books or online content, ensuring that characters like Atticus Finch, Katniss Everdeen, or even ancient heroes like Gilgamesh or the great spy James Bond, inspire and resonate.

  • Understanding Wolfgang Iser’s Phenomenological Approach to Reading

    Wolfgang Iser’s The Reading Process: A Phenomenological Approach 

    Iser’s essay explores how reading a book or story involves more than just passively taking in words. It is an active, creative process where the reader plays a massive role in making the story come to life. The book provides a framework—like a half-finished painting—and the reader adds the colours and details with his/her imagination, experiences, and thoughts. Iser uses ideas from phenomenology (a philosophy about how people experience things) to explain how reading feels like a unique, personal journey for every reader.

    1. Books Have “Gaps” That the Reader Fills In

    **What It Means**

    No book tells a reader every single detail. Stories often leave out details on purpose, such as a character’s thoughts, the reasons behind events, or the exact appearance of a place. Iser calls these missing pieces “gaps” or “blanks.” They’re like empty spaces in a jigsaw puzzle that the reader gets to fill in.

    **Why It Matters**

     These gaps make reading interactive. The author does not spoon-feed a reader with everything; instead, they trust a reader to use his/her imagination to complete the story. This is why reading feels personal—every version of the story is different from someone else’s.

    **Example**

     Imagine reading a story that says, “She walked into the old house and shivered.” The book doesn’t say *why* she shivered. A reader might imagine it’s because the house is cold, creepy, or reminds her of a bad memory. Someone else might picture something different, like she’s excited or nervous. The reader’s imagination fills in the gap, making the story his/her own in the process. 

    **Elaboration** 

    Iser says that these gaps are deliberate. Authors leave them to spark creativity and keep the reader engaged. Without gaps, a story would feel flat, like a boring instruction manual. The gaps give a person room to think, guess, and wonder, which makes reading fun and meaningful. As a reader continues to read, they might fill the gaps differently based on new clues in the story, constantly reshaping their understanding.

     2. You’re Not Just Reading—You’re Creating

    **What It Means**

     When a reader reads, he/she does not just follow the author’s words like a robot. The reader actively builds the story in his/her mind. Take the words, descriptions, and events and turn them into a vivid world in your head, like directing a movie in your imagination.

     **Why It Matters**

     This means every reader creates their version of the story. Background, feelings, and experiences shape how a reader sees the characters, settings, and events. Reading becomes a partnership between the reader and the book.

     **Example**

    In *Harry Potter*, when a reader reads about Hogwarts, the book describes towers and moving staircases, but you imagine what they look like based on their own ideas of a magical castle. If the reader is aware of a castle, seen it before or watched the movies, each Hogwarts might look different from someone else’s who grew up in a different place or culture.

     **Elaboration** 

    Iser emphasises that this creative process is what makes reading special. A reader does not just receive information— they are making choices about how to interpret the story. For instance, if a character is described as “angry,” readers decide how angry they are or what their face looks like based on their own experiences with anger. This active role means no two readers experience the same story, even if they’re reading the exact words.

    3. Reading Is a Personal Experience (Phenomenology)

     **What It Means**

    Iser uses phenomenology, a philosophy that studies how readers experience things in their minds. When they read, the story only exists as they experience it. It’s not just words on a page—it’s the thoughts, feelings, and images that come alive in each reader’s head while reading.

    **Why It Matters**

     This idea shifts the focus from the book itself to *you*, the reader. The story isn’t complete until the reader brings it to life in his/her mind. It’s like the book is a seed, and the imagination is the soil that helps it grow into a whole plant.

     **Example**

     When reading a scary story, a reader might feel his heart race or picture a dark forest. That feeling and those images are *the reader’s* own experience of the story, not just the words. Someone else might read the same story and imagine it differently like feeling nervous but picture a different scene, like a haunted house.

     **Elaboration**

     Iser says that reading is a process that happens over time. As a person moves through a book, their experience evolves. Reading it might feel curious at the start, surprised in the middle, and satisfied (or confused!) by the end. This unfolding experience is what makes reading so engaging—it’s not static, like looking at a painting, but dynamic, like living through an adventure. An individual’s emotions, memories, and expectations all shape how the story feels to them.

    4. The “Implied Reader” Guides the Reader (But You’re Still Free)

    **What It Means**

    Iser talks about the “implied reader,” which is like an imaginary reader the book is written for. The author designs the story with a particular kind of reader in mind, using clues, hints, and gaps to guide how a reader should interpret it. But they are not forced to follow the book’s plan exactly— they still have the freedom to imagine things their way.

    **Why It Matters**

     The implied reader is like a balance between the book’s control and the reader’s creativity. The book nudges them in specific directions, but it’s the readers who decide how to fill in the details.

    **Example**

    In a mystery novel, the author might drop hints about who the culprit is, expecting the implied reader to pick up on them (that’s the implied reader’s role). But the reader might imagine the culprit’s motives or personality differently based on their ideas. The book guides the reader, but they still have room to make the story their own.

    **Elaboration**

     The implied reader is not a real person—it’s a role the readers step into when they read. The book’s structure, like its plot twists or vague descriptions, is designed to make the readers think in specific ways. For example, a romance novel might expect them to root for the main couple, but they might dislike one of the characters based on their (the readers’) values. Iser says that this mix of guidance and freedom is what makes reading a unique collaboration between the text and the reader.

    5. Reading Is a Journey That Changes as You Go

    **What It Means**

    Reading isn’t something readers do all at once—it’s a process that unfolds as they turn the pages. At the start, they might have assumptions about what would happen. As they read more, those assumptions might change based on new information, surprises, or twists.

    **Why It Matters**

     This back-and-forth between what readers expect and what happens keeps them hooked. It’s like a conversation with the book, where they constantly update their understanding.

    **Example**

    In a book like *The Hunger Games*, the reader might start by thinking Katniss is just a tough survivor. As they keep reading, they learn about her love for her sister and her struggles, which changes how they see her. By the end, the readers’ view of her might be different from when they began reading.

    **Elaboration**

     Iser calls this process a mix of *anticipation* (what the reader thinks will happen) and *retrospection* (looking back at what they have read). For example, if a story starts with a mysterious stranger, the reader might anticipate that they are a villain. Later, if the book reveals they’re a hero, the reader looks back and rethinks the earlier clues. This constant updating makes reading feel alive, like solving a puzzle that keeps changing. It’s why the readers might feel excited, confused, or satisfied as they move through a story.

    6. Reading Creates a “Virtual” Story in Mind

    **What It Means**

     While reading, readers create a version of the story in their head that is more than just the words on the page. Iser calls this the “virtual work”—it’s the story as they imagine it, complete with the scenes, feelings, and meanings they have added.

    **Why It Matters**

    This virtual story is what makes reading feel magical. It’s not just about what the author wrote but about the world they build in their mind. It’s why books can feel so real and emotional.

    **Example**

     When reading about a character eating a delicious meal, the book might describe the food, but readers picture it based on their favourite foods or memories of a great dinner. That vivid image in their head is part of the virtual story they create.

    **Elaboration**

    Iser says this virtual story is the heart of the aesthetic experience of reading. It’s not just about understanding the plot but about living through the story through imagination. For instance, when reading a fantasy book, readers might picture dragons soaring over mountains, even if the book only says, “a dragon flew overhead.” The implied reader’s mind adds the colours, sounds, and emotions, making the story feel like it’s happening to the reader. This creative act is what makes reading different from just watching a movie, where the images are already provided.

    Importance of Iser’s Ideas

    Iser’s theory flips the way of thinking about books. Instead of focusing only on what the author meant or what the story says, he puts *you*, the reader, at the centre. Reading becomes a creative act where readers not only follow the story but also help to shape it. This explains why:

    – Two people can read the same book and have different reactions.

    – Rereading a book feels different because the same readers’ ideas have changed since the last time they read it.

    – Books feel personal, like they’re speaking directly to readers.

    His ideas also connect to bigger questions about how to find meaning in art, stories, and even life. By saying that meaning comes from readers’ interaction with the text, Iser shows that stories are alive, changing with every reader and every reading.

    A Real-Life Analogy

    Think of reading like baking a cake with a recipe. The book is the recipe—it gives the readers the basic ingredients and steps (plot, characters, setting). But the reader, who is the baker, decides how to mix it, what kind of frosting to add, and how to decorate it. Like adding extra chocolate because they love it or imagining the cake as a birthday surprise for someone special. The final cake (the story in readers’ mind) is unique because of the choices they made, even though they started with the same recipe as everyone else.

    Conclusion 

    Iser’s “The Reading Process” says that reading is a creative, personal adventure. Books leave gaps for readers to fill with their imagination, making every story unique. As they read, they build a “virtual” version of the story in their mind, shaped by their experiences and expectations. The book guides a reader like a map, but they choose the path, making reading a dynamic process that changes as the reader goes. This makes every book a special collaboration between the author’s words and the readers’ imagination, turning reading into a profoundly personal and meaningful experience.

  • A Short History of English Literature

    English literature, with its rich tapestry of narratives, has evolved through centuries, reflecting the socio-political changes, cultural shifts, and intellectual movements that have shaped the English-speaking world. This journey can be traced through several distinct periods, each contributing unique voices and genres to the literary canon.

    1. The Old English Period (450-1066):

    The roots of English literature can be traced back to the Anglo-Saxon era. The most renowned work of this period is the epic poem “Beowulf,” which narrates the heroic exploits of its titular character. This era predominantly featured oral traditions and poetry, characterized by strong rhythms and alliteration.

    2. The Middle English Period (1066-1500):

    Following the Norman Conquest, English literature began to evolve significantly. Geoffrey Chaucer’s “The Canterbury Tales” stands out as a monumental work from this period, depicting a diverse array of characters and stories within a pilgrimage setting. This period also saw the emergence of Arthurian legends, with works such as Sir Thomas Malory’s “Le Morte d’Arthur.”

    3. The Renaissance (1500-1660):

    The Renaissance brought a renewed interest in classical learning and humanism. This period is marked by the works of William Shakespeare, whose plays and sonnets explore themes of love, power, identity, and the human condition. Other notable figures include Christopher Marlowe, Edmund Spenser, and John Milton, whose “Paradise Lost” remains a cornerstone of epic poetry.

    4. The Neoclassical Period (1660-1798):

    Characterized by its emphasis on order, reason, and decorum, the Neoclassical period drew inspiration from classical antiquity. Authors like Alexander Pope, with his satirical “The Rape of the Lock,” and Jonathan Swift, known for “Gulliver’s Travels,” critiqued contemporary society and politics. The period also saw the rise of the novel, with Daniel Defoe’s “Robinson Crusoe” and Samuel Richardson’s “Pamela.”

    5. The Romantic Period (1798-1837):

    Romanticism emerged as a reaction against the industrial revolution and neoclassical ideals. It celebrated emotion, nature, and individualism. Poets such as William Wordsworth, Samuel Taylor Coleridge, and Lord Byron are emblematic of this era. The Gothic novel also gained popularity, with Mary Shelley’s “Frankenstein” becoming a timeless classic.

    6. The Victorian Period (1837-1901):

    The Victorian era was marked by rapid industrialization, social reform, and the expansion of the British Empire. Charles Dickens’s novels, such as “Oliver Twist” and “Great Expectations,” highlighted social injustices and the plight of the poor. The Brontë sisters, Thomas Hardy, and George Eliot also made significant contributions, exploring themes of love, morality, and societal constraints.

    7. The Modernist Period (1901-1945):

    Modernism represented a break from traditional forms and a quest for new artistic expressions. This period was influenced by World War I and the rapid changes in society. James Joyce’s “Ulysses,” Virginia Woolf’s “Mrs Dalloway,” and T.S. Eliot’s “The Waste Land” exemplify modernist experimentation with narrative techniques and stream-of-consciousness writing.

    8. The Contemporary Period (1945-Present):

    Post-World War II literature has seen a diversification of voices and themes. Postcolonial literature, feminist literature, and the rise of digital media have all influenced contemporary writing. Authors like Salman Rushdie, Margaret Atwood, and Zadie Smith reflect the multicultural and globalized nature of modern English literature.

    Each of these periods has left an indelible mark on the landscape of English literature, contributing to its rich and diverse heritage. From the heroic tales of Beowulf to the postmodern narratives of today, the evolution of English literature is a testament to the enduring power of storytelling and the human imagination.

  • A Few Notable Sources on Literary Theories

    Abrams, M.H., and Geoffrey Galt Harpham. A Handbook of Literary Terms.

    Agarwal, B R., M P Sinha.  Most Trends in the Post-Independence Indian English Fiction. New  Delhi: Atlantic Publishers and Distributors, 2003. Print

    Alam, Fakrul. “Amitav Ghosh (1956- )”. Writers of the Indian Diaspora: A Bio-Bibliographical Critical Source. Ed. Emmanuel S. Nelson. Connecticut: Greenwood Press, 1993.

    Anderson, Benedict. Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of  Nationalism. Rev ed. 1983. New York: Verso, 2006.

    Appadurai, Arjun. “Disjuncture and Difference in the Global Cultural Economy”. Theory,  Culture & Society. 7.2 (1990): SAGE, London.          <http://tcs.sagepub.com>

    Ashcroft, Bill., Gareth Griffiths, and Helen Tiffins. Post Colonial Studies: The Key Concepts. New York: Routledge Taylor and Francis Group, 2000. Print

    “Bacon, Francis”. Stanford Encyclopaedia of Philosophy. Rev ed. Dec. 2012. <http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/francis-bacon/>  

    Ashcroft, Bill., Gareth Griffiths, and Helen Tiffins. The Empire Writes Back. 2nd ed. London: Routledge, 1989.                     

    Baral, K.C. “Imagining India: Nation and Narration”. Rethinking Indian English Literature.  Ed. U.M. Nanavati, and Prafulla C. Kar. Delhi: Pencraft International, 2000.

    Barry, Peter. Beginning Theory. 2nd ed. New York: Manchester UP, 1995. Print.

    Bauböck, Rainer., Thomas Faist. Diaspora and Transnationalism: Concepts, Theories and Methods. Amsterdam: Amsterdam UP, 2010.     

    Bridgman, Elijah Coleman, ed. “Primary Source 13.0 1 Lin  Zexu, Letter To Queen Victoria (1839) 1”. The Chinese Repository. Vol.8.10 (Feb1940)

    Brubaker, Rogers. “The ‘Diaspora’ Diaspora”. Ethnic and Racial Studies. 28.1 (Jan 2005)

    Carr, E.H. What is History?

    Castle, Gregory. The Blackwell Guide to Literary Theory. USA: Blackwell Publishing, 2007.

    Chakrabarty, Dipesh, “A Correspondence on Provincializing Europe.” Radical History Review 3  (2002)

    Choudhury. M.K. “Postmodernism and Fiction”. Multiple Contexts and Insights: Studies in Contemporary Literature. Eds. Shukla, Sheobhushan and Anu Shukla. New Delhi: Sarup & Sons, 2003

    Choudhry, Sanjay. “Family in Contemporary Postcolonial Literature in English”. Companion to Postcolonial Literature in English. Ed. New Delhi: DPS, 2010

    Clifford, James. “Diasporas”. Cultural Anthropology 9.3 (Aug 1994

    Cohen, Robin. “Diasporas and the State: from Victims to Challenges”. International Affairs 72.3  (1996)

    Cohen, Roger. “Ethnic Cleansing”. Crimes of War. 2011.<http://www.crimesofwar.org/a-z-guide/ethnic-cleansing/>

    Cohen, Robin. Global Diasporas: An Introduction. 2nd ed. 2008.    http://andrewblackman.net/2010/04/globaldiasporasanintroductionbyrobincohen/

    “Contemporary Indian Literature in English and the Indian Market”. The Open University.

    Daiya, Kavita. “Home and the Nation: Women, Citizenship and Transnational Migration in Postcolonial Literature.” Journal of Postcolonial Writing. (Dec 2008)

  • Greek and Roman Gods and Goddesses

    Greek and Roman Gods and Goddesses

    There are many theories and reasons behind the birth of civilisations. Mythology plays a vital role in making that civilisation concrete. It contains many legends, tales, folklore, heroes, and more. Any civilisation originated long ago with the ancient people trying to bring humanity to the next level.

    The word civilisation comes from the Latin “civitas” or “city”. The first four civilisations built were the Mesopotamians, Egyptians, the Indus Valley, and the Chinese.

    All such societies have mythologies about their culture, love for nature, honour, and devotion to their creators or gods. Such honour can still be seen in the beautiful monuments, temples, historical buildings, cathedrals and even some local buildings. They remind the people of ancient Greece, Rome, and other religious deities and Gods to teach them their culture, their relationship with the gods, their ancestral worship, the balance between good and evil, their respect and fears towards others creations, and the afterlife.

    Thus, many mythologies were created, combining facts and stories. When people think of mythology, they are usually reminded of Greek and Roman mythology, known for its grandeur and knots. Zeus, Hercules, Athena, and Poseidon are a few well-known names associated with such legendary myths. Several movies represent these characters, including Hercules and Clash of the Titans.

    The following are the Gods, Goddesses, heroes that are equivalent on both countries.

    Chaos was the origin of the cosmos and time according to the Greek mythology.

    UranusUranusFather of the Titans  
    ZeusJupiterKing of Gods  
    HeraJuno  Goddess of Marriage
    PoseidonNeptuneGod of the Sea  
    CronusSaturnYoungest son of Uranus; Father of Zeus  
    AphroditeVenusGoddess of love  
    HadesPlutoGod of the Underworld  
    AresMarsGod of War  
    EosAurora  Goddess of the Dawn
    HeraclesHerculesSon of Zeus  
    OdysseusUlyssesGreek and Roman Hero  
    SeleneLuna.Goddess of the Moon  
    GaiaTerraGoddess of Earth  
    ErosCupid  God of love
    PanFaun  God of Shepherds
    HeliosSol  The Sun God
    HephaestusVulcanGod of the Forge and  Sculpture
    DemeterCeres  Goddess of the Harvest
    NikeVictoria  Goddess of Victory
    RheaOps  Mother of Zeus
    Hypnos / HypnusSomnus  God of Sleep
    Nyx   Goddess of Night / Mother of Hypnos
    Erebus   God of Darkness
  • The Religion of England

    All the people of England were the members of the Christian church in one way or another. Pope in Rome was regarded as the head of the church. Later, during the reformation, people were divided and there evolved two groups, namely, the Catholics and the Protestants. When the Catholics were loyal to the Pope, the people who protested certain doctrines of the church became the Protestants who were against the Pope. 

    Anglicanism and Catholicism

    Anglicanism or Catholicism was considered the main national religion of then England. They are both Christian churches and rely on the Eastern Orthodox churches. Both the Anglicans and Roman Catholics were much similar in reading the Bible and yet differed in various ways. Catholics consider the hierarchy in the church and the Catholic Priests do not marry, whereas the Anglicans did not accept the supremacy of the Pope and their priests were married.  

    Head of the Church of England

    As Anglicanism was the official religion of England, most of the people belonged to the Church of England. It was mostly connected by a network of parishes. And each of this parish was in the charge of a Rector or Vicar. The Archbishops of Canterbury in the South and York in the North were powerful and superior and the King or the Queen was the real head of the Church of England. 

    Divisions 

    In the 17th century there was a division into two groups namely the high church and the low church. The high church members gave a high place to authority whereas the low church members did not give a high place to authority. There was no difference between the rituals of the Roman Catholics and the Anglo Catholics except that they did not accept the supremacy of the Pope. 

    Non-Conformists 

    Queen Elizabeth brought about certain reforms to which certain people did not conform. They were the people who were nicknamed Puritans. They wanted to purify the Church of England of all Roman Catholic practices. Their descendants were known as Dissenters. Those dissenters were called Non-Conformists and the most important of which were the Methodists, the Baptists, the Congregationists, the Presbyterians and Quakers or the member of the Society of Friends

    Methodism 

    Methodism was the closest to the Church of England and was started in 1729. They were named Methodists for the way they had followed methodically in practising their Christian faith.

    John Wesley and George Wakefield were the leaders of the group. Wesley believed in Armenianism and Whitefield believed in Calvin’s doctrine. In 1795 the methodists became an independent body and in 1932 the methodist bodies became united. 

    The Baptists 

    The Baptists, as a sect came into existence in the middle of the seventeenth century. They believed that faith is a fact between the God and an individual. The most famous of England Baptists was John Bunyan who famously wrote the book, The Pilgrim’s Progress. Baptist belief was introduced into America in 1639 by Roger Williams. 

    It’s basic belief was that the only people who have professed their faith can be baptised, unlike the infant baptism practiced by most other Christian faiths. The Baptist missionary society founded in 1792 was the first English organisation for foreign missions. 

    Congregationalism 

    This started with the Protestant Reformation. One of the groups separated themselves completely from them and called themselves Congregationalists. For them, Christ was the only head of the church and the Bible was a sufficient role of faith. 

    Presbyterians

    They were a group of Protestant Christians without Bishops; they were predominant in their reformation period. They displaced the Church of England at least for a time. It is rooted in the  Protestant Reformation of the sixteenth century. When the Catholic church did not accept the reformers, there emerged a number of other theological movements with different denominations as this one.

    Quakerism or the Society of Friends 

    Quakers are the people who belong to a Protestant Christian set of denominations historically known as the Religious Society of Friends. This was established during the short period of between 1648 and 1650 by George Fox.  They were called quakers because they quacked when they spoke under divine inspiration . They had the faith that every man was guided by God. They were against all doctrines and they also did a lot of charitable works.  William Penn and Elizabeth Fry were the famous quakers. 

    Unitarianism 

    Unitarianism basically denied the doctrine of Trinity. It prevailed in the mid nineteenth century and became a religion of reason. It was under the leadership of James Martineau of England. Several other notable people are Ralph Waldo Emerson and Theodore Parker of the United States, S T Coleridge,  Elizabeth Gaskell and Sir Isaac Newton. 

    Adventists

    Adventists were the various groups of Christians who had believed that the second coming of Christ was most imminent.  The first coming of Christ was as the savior of the world the second coming of Christ was expected to be as a Judge of mankind. The Seventh-day Adventists Church considered Saturday as their day of rest. 

  • The Old and the New Diaspora

    An ‘ideal’ type of ‗Diaspora‘ refers to the exile of the Jews. The African experience of ‘slavery’ under the colonial rule had also created equally tormenting circumstances to those ‘slaves’. Soon after the abolition of slavery, a new system emerged that created a large amount of migrants to most of the British colonies. Ashcroft, Griffiths and Tiffins in their Post Colonial Studies: The Key Concepts explains When slavery was finally outlawed in colonial systems such as Britain’s, it was replaced by an extension of a system of employment called indentured labour. Although, as the term implies, indenture contracts were apparently voluntarily entered into, in practice this operated as a system of forced labour, with many of the labourers impressed rather than recruited. Indenture became the main means of securing cheap labour after 1833, supplying the workers for British colonial plantations in locations as widespread as Fuji, Malaya, Northern Queensland and of course the Caribbean. Many diasporic groups, notably Indians and Chinese were transported under this system. Consequently, even after the formal abolition of slavery, various forms of forced or contracted labour, such as indenture in English colonies, and debt peonage in Latin America, meant that oppressive labour habits died hard in these regions, where the forms of agriculture developed under the slave system required a continued supply of cheap and controlled labour, cheap and controlled labour. (215)

    As stated by Professor Amit Kumar Mishra, University of Hyderabad, in his essay ―Sardars, Kanganies and Maistries: Intermediaries in the Indian Labour Diaspora during the Colonial Period‖, the British planters were worried about the problem of seeking labour searching after the abolition of slavery in the Parliament on 1 August 1834 which created a sense of anxiety and insecurity among them. Hence they started the new system of recruiting contract labourers for plantations. This new capitalist system in the nineteenth century became successful as large number of Indians migrated to the newly expanded plantations in colonies like Mauritius. The British had worked for the supply of contract labourers initially in African and East European colonies which ended up in failure. Only later they had turned towards the over populated Asian countries. To ensure the availability of migrant labourers in abundance, the plantation lobby preferred the contract system in contrast to free labour. Contracts ensured the availability of labourers for a fixed period with the possibility of further extension. To obtain labourers under such a system, there were some initial experimentations with African and East European immigrants. When these proved to be a failure, planters resorted to looking for a supply of contract labourers from the ‗densely populated‘ regions of Asia – China, Japan, India and few a Pacific Islands. Indeed, these regions did historically satisfy the demands stemming from the rapidly growing plantation settlements. (4). This new system of labour recruitments had been divided into two types accordingly. The first type was the indentured labourers and the second type was the Sardars, Kanganies and Masteries. Mishra emphasises that the nineteenth century had been a century of “men moving”(4) which has been recorded as the gigantic mass human displacement for labour across the nations. This system was brought to notice by other 128 European nations following the abolition of slavery in those colonies as well. Emigration of Indian indentured labourers was not confined to the British settlements. Following the abolition of slavery in French colonies in 1846 and in Dutch ones as of 1863, planters there also entered into agreements with their colonial governments to acquire labourers from India. Subsequently, the French Caribbean received 79,089 Indian labourers between 1851 and 1890 and Dutch Guiana (Suriname) received more than 34,000 Indian labourers between 1873 and 1916. (4). The labourers were sent from different regions in India. Their migration process was carried out under the government regulation only in three major ports, namely Calcutta, Bombay and Madras. The main regions supplying labourers were: tribal regions of Chota Nagpur in eastern India; Saran, Chapra, Shahabad, Champaran, Gaya, and Patna in Bihar; Banaras, Ghazipur, Azamgarh, Gorakhpur, Basti, Bahraich, Jaunpur in the United Provinces; Chingalpet, Tanjore, Trichirapally, South and North Arcot, Salem, Coimbatore, Vizagapatam in southern India; and the Ratnagiri region in western India. In the initial period, a mixed lot of emigrants embarked for different colonies where emigrants came from from diverse regions. (6).

    Though there had been many forms of migration, indentured labourer system 129 holds the mark in creating a large mass migration from India. This form of diaspora belongs to the colonial phase which had two options to decide from-either to return back to their homeland after the stipulated time of their contract for five years or to continue their stay by accepting another contract to work as indentured labourer and to buy a piece of land for themselves if affordable. As TLS Bhaskar explains it, the process of immigrating to the plantation was governed by an Immigration Ordinance which would be enacted in the country of destination, The prospective emigrants testified before a Magistrate in India and the terms of the contract as required under the British administration (Jain, Ibid). The recruitment process involved emigration agents, sub- agents and depots in the rural areas. The chief features of the indenture system, “…were five years of stereotyped state regulated labor, denial of the right to change the employer or employment, recruitment of labor units and not families, gross disproportions of men to women, changes for recruitment by the employer, and the denial of increased wages in spite of increased prices and profits. (5) Bhaskar also emphasises on the recruitment process as stated by Singh that the recruiters of the indentured labourer had instructions to choose them mainly from the agricultural background which would help them run the plantations well due to lack of enough labourers. The Ministry of External Affairs planned a High Level Committee on Indian Diaspora which published a report in 2000. It has demonstrated an analysis on Indian Diaspora regarding its culture. As mentioned by Oonk, the report says that the “Members of Indian Diaspora are deeply conscious of their rich cultural heritage. They are aware that they are the inheritors of the traditions of the world’s oldest continuous civilisation. Being part of such a rich legacy, they are naturally keen to maintain their cultural identity.” (403). The report further states that the survey, taken on Indian diaspora residing in their host lands shows that labourers did not experienced conflict with their fellow citizens of the countries where they reside which clearly according to the report is due to their commitment to the tradition and civilisation ethos of India which have been imbibed not only into the illiterate indentured labourers of highly qualified professionals but also by their descendants. Keeping in mind that the term Diaspora is a metaphorical term which derives its metaphor from the field of agriculture, associated with the dispersion of seeds or scattering of seeds the migration of indentured labourers in search of a livelihood cannot be seen in the same way as the initial ascription of the forced migration of the Jews from Palestine. As explained by Fernando Galvan in the article ―Metaphors of Diaspora‖, The first is an agricultural metaphor associated with the idea of dispersion, of sowing or scattering seeds (from the Greek diá ‗through‘, and the verb speirein ‗to sow‘, ‗to scatter‘). Moreover, its initial metaphorical ascription to the dispersion of a particular people, the Jews, after the Babylonian captivity, and then later, with the Jewish people being forced to leave Palestine, has been extended to other peoples and communities. Thus the classical, Jewish diaspora has carried over its meaning, extending it to other similar dispersions: we now view the African diaspora, the Asian diaspora, the Indian diaspora, and others, as equivalent to (similar to or 131 like) the Jewish diaspora. (114) Such has become the impact of diaspora across the world and it is important to note that the Indian Diaspora holds its own position of difference in it. It does not only represent the migration of people, but the world of culture as well. The essay by Ghosh, ―The Modern Indian Diaspora‖ – the huge migration from the subcontinent that began in the mid-nineteenth century- is not merely one of the most important demographic dislocations of modern times: it now represents an important force in world culture. The culture of the diaspora is also increasingly a factor within the culture of the Indian Subcontinent‖. (243) Hence, it is equally important to distinguish between the ‗forced‘ and ‗chosen‘ need based migrations. Diaspora which has come to represent the migrants has been categorised into ‗old‘ and ‗new‘ diasporas by considering the lives of the migrants and by the struggles they had to undergo under the British rule. As Ghosh explains the ‗old‘ diaspora has emerged well in the mid of the nineteenth century during the British colonisation. Though there had been a few Indian‘s who migrated for trade purposes a whole lot of people started migrating only during the nineteenth century which was the result of the trade undertaken by the British through India. As put forth by Dr. Vinay Lal in his essay, ―Living in the Shadows‖, the Indian diaspora as known and referred to by the people has started mainly into the countries like U.S.A., Australia, Canada, the Middle East and a little lesser in the U.K. A wide range of its global presence has been experienced in all these countries through various cultural phenomena like, ―Bollywood, Indian Writing in English, tandoori cooking and even the emergence of a new class of aggressive Indian business tycoons‖ (2)

    All the successful stories told by ―diasporic‖ Indians at large to other middle class Indians have centred on a clear image that such countries provide them a bright future and hence thrive to move to these destinations themselves. Such a painting would be stained by the real fact that the great mass of migration, the real diaspora of the Indian dates back to the nineteenth century and that their land of destinations were not the US or UK but to the southeast Asian countries, the Caribbean Islands and several other countries like Mauritius and Fiji. Mostly subjugated ancestral diasporic Indians had taken with them the agonies and struggles of their lives and being washed away from their familial bounds and to be left behind by working for the East India Company during the period of the first Governor General Warren Hastings in 1780. Though migration started during the period of the production of opium, many people fled to other countries for plantations and as farmers, thereby toiling too hard for a little amount of money paid to them. Several bonds had been made with these migrants either to stay in their colonies or to leave in a few years with whatever they are given. This agonizing era, has in turn changed and developed into an era of mainly of the professional elites who have migrated under various pull and push factors and have established themselves in different aspects and various fields of development. As a matter of fact, Dr. Lal explains how the Indian Diaspora cannot be written so easily based on the success stories and accounting to these few people‘s lives. He says, the story of the Indian diaspora can scarcely be written in the singular idiom of resounding successes, stories of the rags to riches, or of the entrepreneurial drive of people determined to make their mark in life. Certain elementary distinctions are the bedrock of understanding why some diasporic Indian Communities are more liable to suffer from political, economic or social disabilities than others, and what might be the systemic forms of exclusion or oppression which have operated to keep some diasporic communities on the margin. (2) This ‗old‘ diaspora of the nineteenth century is said to be a truly great saga of people who made their way as indentured labourers to various countries like Mauritius, Trinidad, Fiji, Surinam, Guyana, South Africa and several other places under the British colonies. These experiences and tumultuous voyages have attracted the recent scholars to delve deep into their lifestyle and had attracted a few, Indian writers who were interested to acknowledge their existence that still have serious impacts on the generations of the early migrants. Especially in the recent years it is being acknowledged officially by the Government of India and as a nation come forward to celebrate and respect the sacrifices by the early migrants by arranging the annual celebrations known as Pravasi Bharatiya Diwas in order to pay them respect from 2003 onwards. This sort of response by India towards its people, its own diaspora brings disappointment upon the country‘s government which yields all its possession to itself yet neglecting those historical moments and voyages of mass migration. It is much more surprising to have known the hidden fact through Ghosh‘s interviews that such migrations had happened not at the coastal areas of the country but from the interior parts of the country. The nation, ―Mother India‖ (2), as Lal calls India, has neglected its responsibility to safeguard and uphold its own divergent communities apart from their social, economic and religious differences. The earlier times had been much worse than this as the overseas Indians were given least concern by India during the crisis in Uganda and Kenya. Lal poses a doubt if ―the expulsions of Indians from Uganda and Kenya in the late 1960‘s might have been 134 overlooked had many of them not had British citizenship and considerable assets at their command‖. (2). When Ghosh discusses it in his essay ―The Diaspora in Indian Culture‖, he says, ―…, the relationship between India and its diaspora is very real. On at least two occasions – the Uganda crisis and the recent crisis in Fiji – the Indian Government did actually resort to real political brinkmanship on behalf of its diaspora. Its efforts may not have amounted to very much in either case – a fact for which the diaspora will probably of a poor and relatively impotent nation, it did what little it could. (247). Further he raises a question of ―why for the populations of Uganda and Fiji were not Indian citizens and India owed them no obligations‖. (247) As told by him, the Indian government has acted indifferently towards its own old diaspora, as the country, India is poor and has comparatively little political influence in influencing ―the conduct of other nation states‖ (2). The bitter fact is that the country is filled with its own cold war and politics to indulge in such aspects leading it to an inadequate or an incompetent situation, thus creating problems in retaining the country‘s old diaspora. Caste and cultural discrimination and differences themselves might have been the hurdles to embrace the diasporic communities away from their traumatic situations. Lal provides another perspective where in the other reasons for India to neglect the communities is because the diasporic communities were the indentured labourers who are just a level above the Africans who had been considered to be born as slaves carrying the burdens of their masters: And yet there may have been other significant considerations that perhaps explain why India was generally not keen to embrace its dispersed children around the world. If one recalls a well-known scholars‘ controversial characterization of indentured labour, which accounts for the bulk of early Indian migrations, as another name for slavery (Tinker 1947), one begins to suspect that the disapprobation with which many Indians have received this term has to do with much more than question of historical accuracy or even scholarly predilections. (3) This act of not considering the diasporic communities shows the fragility of the country which has been very much ready in submitting itself to the colonial rule, subjugating the whole nation and its people. Yet the same vulnerability has brought in strength to a few people of the country who had made use of the colonial rule for their own good and turning their lives into a bed of roses, thereby neglecting the impact that it would create on their countrymen. On the contrary, migration has also brought unity among the migrants who have left their families behind in forming new families and hope for the betterment of their lives in the land that they are destined to live in. Hence, by the mid – 1990s we begin to see the differentiation between the ‗old‘ diaspora and the ‗new‘ diaspora; the former comprising the labourers and the latter comprising the professional elites who have started developing themselves out of the fragility of the nation. In short, the ‗new‘ diaspora has been oblivious about the ‗old‘ diaspora to march towards progress among the various developments and conflicts between the nation and its people. The Government of India has turned its back to the ‗lost‘ history of the early migration, busying itself in the development of the country by joining hands with the professional elites who were unwilling to protect their own ancestors‘ history and their past. The ‗old‘ diaspora was no more an exclusively working-class diaspora than the ‗new‘ diaspora was a diaspora comprising only professional elites. The Pravasi Bharatiya Diwas gatherings in New Delhi were designed to invoke an ecumenical conception of the Indian diaspora that, as I have previously suggested, the government of India has almost always disowned. As I have also argued, the Indian government, and no less the educated elites of India, were oblivious to the presence of an older Indian diaspora and were predisposed towards viewing it as a reminder of everything that India had to leave behind if it wished to be seen as a nation marching towards progress and development. There was more than a touch of poverty in the older Indian diaspora, given its origins in the migrations of labourers often suffering from destitution, and most of all what India sought was to refurbish its image abroad so that India would not be indelibly stamped as a land of seething poverty. (3) The ‗old‘ had been left behind in order to march towards progress and development of the still developing ‗New‘ country amidst competitions and business or even due to political issues in the era of globalisation. The ‗old‘ remains ―as the reminder of everything that India had to leave behind if it wished to be seen as a nation marching towards progress and development‖ (3), says Lal by pointing at the cold hands of the country towards its own people who had brought miseries to themselves to make amends for their families and the nation they left behind to suffer destitution and lost deep within the image created by India as a land of developing prospects and not ―a land of seething poverty‖ (3). This attitude changed when it was demanded to have equal prominence and oppose discrimination openly.

    Lal is of the opinion that ―The inescapable conclusion appears to be that Indians can be oppressed without much consequence to the oppressor.‖ (4), which proves to be accurate in the above circumstances. For, some people were taken as indentured labourers to various lands for plantation purposes of the British when India was in the hands British as British Raj to escape from their personal hardships. The people who opted for such a journey happened to settle in those foreign lands, though they longed to return to their homeland which was a miracle at times. Most of the migrants were from the North, Bhojpuri speaking people working in the sugarcane plantations. The Indian settlers of Trinidad and Fiji had never been much in touch with India, like the people who settled in Malaysia who were in contact constantly which may be due to the distance between the countries which are nearby to kindle their nostalgia for their homeland. Yet the Indians are outnumbered by the indigenous Malays and the Chinese who are the next great migrant people. Whereas, Trinidad and Fiji have the population divided, if not equally but smoothly between the Afro-Trinidadians and Indians and the Indo-Fijians. Indians settled in South Africa are classed as one among the four major groups which included the Europeans, and even the Africans who are categorised as ―‗coloreds‘‖ (4). The Indian diasporic community of each of these countries has its own pros and cons, as it is dominated by the host country‘s indigenous people or the already settled people. Trinidad had its own political and racial views and issues in dealing with the large group of Indian community. As per Lal, the Indians had first landed in Trinidad through sea in FatelRozack on 30 May 1845, just a decade after the abolition of the term ‗slavery‘. They had been the large yet cheap group of labourers who were supposed to provide profits for their landlords and the oppressors. This highly appreciable hard work has been paid attention to and praised by one of the greatest Afro-Trinidadian novelists, George Lamming (1989) who has written that the Indians ―humanised the landscape. Tilled the soil, and put the food on the table (Lal 1996:133-42)‖ (4). He has not only spoken about the landscape and agriculture but also about the human values on humanitarian grounds. This has changed in time over two or three generations, let alone the common celebration of Muharram, the Shiva festival which in due course became a common festival for the people of all religions. This attitude has changed gradually when the new generations stepped out of agriculture and educated themselves that led to ―greed and exploitative nature‖ (5) which was brought to control politically. In the later period, the Indian community became the victims under the Afro-Trinidadians who have become indifferent to their sufferings, which is the present situation of the country. An important aspect to be noted is that the Trinidad Indian community holds the pride of becoming the first diasporic community to mark their presence with an Indian Arrival Day which was established in 1995 after various clarifications and proposals. The confusions did not stop here since the government of Trinidad & Tobago declared 1 August, the Emancipation Day, as a national holiday, as though the country had only the black community. ―Suddenly it seemed that both Indo-Trinidadians and AfroTrinidadians were rivals to laying claim to the history of Trinidad, with little or no recognition in the part of either that they were, perhaps, equally interlopers in a country whose native inhabitants had been exterminated‖. (6). Though the abolition of slavery in 1835 resulted in the arrival of the Indians to Trinidad, it also resulted in the arrival of the Africans who behaved in a ―diabolical‖ (6) manner in exterminating the native inhabitants of Trinidad. After the arrival of Patrick Manning as Prime Minister the national holiday ‗Arrival Day‘. It was changed again as the ‗Indian Arrival Day‘ with the help of Basdeo Panday, the former Prime Minister. The situation was almost the same even in Fiji, where the Indian community was left to struggle among Fiji‘s population. The Indians were brought to the land of Fiji as indentured labourers to work in the Australia based sugar plantations in 1879. The circumstances of the people changed from bad to the worse as the women who thought to have attained the economic freedom in the new land had only been pushed into violence in extreme forms of displacement, as they were unaware of the social and political system of that country. Women were forced into sexual abuse and the living conditions according to them were ―narak (hell). (Voigt-Graf 2004: 179)‖ (6), which is termed by a scholar as ‗prison-like‘ (Naidu 2004). Indian labourers have been the reason behind the development of Queensland and New South Wales through their labour which brought profits on the farmed lands. This historical event of the Indians in the land of Fiji has been concealed by certain forces of the ethnic Fijians and Europeans, leaving behind the Indians estranged to suffer in their hands ―… as though any recognition of the suffering of Indians undermines our understanding of the manner in which ethnic Fijians (or Melanesians) were deliberately confined by the colonial state to their native villages under the threat of draconian sanctions,…‖ (7), which is a trick followed by the British to isolate themselves from a modern economy. The Indians living there still till the soil apart from not being given more lands for their purpose and for various reasons that still prevail. South African Indian communities of labourers immigrated to the land first in 1860 in Natal. Their presence brought a drastic change in the production of sugar and even in other forms of agriculture which resulted in strong objections on account of their removal from the land. They have been accused of being violent on the rest of the South African community which was eventually rejected by the South African Human Rights Commissioner ―taints an entire community‖ (10). The Indian indentured labourers were taken mostly from the South India, especially from Tamil Nadu. A large number of Indians were brought to Malaysia between 1911 and 1930. Being a multicultural society, Malaysia has been dominant in holding the Government jobs for itself while the Chinese diasporic community held the business to itself. Indians were left alone with the plantations in which they cherished until recently providing them the income only through the available crops. Such had been the condition of the Indian diasporic community that migrated to Trinidad, South Africa and Southeast Asian countries whose predicament has been uncertain. Though the democratical Government of Fiji was held by an Indian there was no room for the Indians to be strong against the crimes and discriminations committed upon them and to uphold them away from being kept on the margins of the civil society. Indians are the majority in these countries and yet they are treated as minorities for their fragility and yet they make a difference in their confidence; i.e., the minorities with confidence as the majorities.

  • Susan Sontag’s Essay “Against Interpretation”

    Susan Sontag is an avante-guarde writer (who discards conventions) who belongs to the American school of criticism. She has written novels like The Benefactor (1964) and Death Kit (1968) . “Notes on Camp”, an essay was first published in 1964, and was republished in 1966 in her collection of essays, Against Interpretation. 

    Susan Sontag in her essay “Against Interpretation” focuses on what an interpretation really is. She discusses and mixes the ideas of other writers and further differentiates two kinds of interpretation – form based interpretation and content based interpretation.

    She talks about the past with the present interpretation. Nothing was rejected in classical interpretation. She believes that it was the classical period which gave importance to ‘content’ of a work other than meaning and other things. She also believes that margins are always inverted. The title “against” does not mean that Sontag is against interpretation, rather it questions those that are against and tries to defend interpretation. 

    Hence, Sontag advocates against interpretations of a work that plays more importance in finding the meaning, message, intention in a work. She strongly believes that in trying to establish the content of a work the interpreter avoids the form of the work. This is because it has been believed that literature or any work of art has two major functions; – ‘to teach’ and ‘to delight’ in trying to assimilate art into thought or art into culture. An interpreter exercises all the sensory experiences to set up a “shadow world of meanings” and “turn the world into this world”. The world here she refers to is the text in all it’s gestalt glory and this is what the interpreter recreates. Hence, the world of art gets depleted and impoverished in the transformation of ‘the’ to ‘this’ work, art or world. 

    Sontag traces interpretation with all its doubtful, corollaries, to the classical theory of art as mimesis (imitation) of reality. Plato speaks of the value of art being dubious, since the poet-creator is “twice removed from reality”. Therefore art was neither useful nor true. Aristotle disputed this idea and interpreted that art is “medicinally useful in arousing and purging dangerous emotions” (catharsis). Here, Aristotle does not reject Plato but only adds more meaning to substantiate and defend the value of both the poet and his heart. She argues that, yet they both have looked upon art as (in Freudian terms) manifest content with the intention to communicate meanings alone. Until the advent of New Criticism, the study of ‘form’ was never given a serious thought or exercised diligently. Form is present in all animate and inanimate things even as content is. Modern theorists following soon after the formalist school believed the theory of art as a subjective expression to the point of viewing art as semiotics (study of signs) and power relationships.

    Irrespective of the conceptions on the theories of art, whether art is a picture of social reality or of language, the content of it is what all finally look to (that something it says or it is trying to say or it has said). The only difference is in classical theory interpretation, only alter in order to reconcile meaning where insistent but respectful in their opinions and give one more meaning to the existing meaning without rejecting the original. On the other hand, modern theorists were radical, aggressive and dismissive in their act of interpretation. These modern theorists acting as interpreters question the truth and started excavating in order to create new meanings by “digging behind the text”. That is, in the classical period of interpretation, the old is not discarded but only revamped. On the contrary, modern interpreters discarded established truths in order to recreate their own. Therefore interpretation does not give absolute and complete meaning that is it does not have absolute and complete meaning; that is, it does not have absolute value. On the other hand, Sontag believes interpretation must be self-evaluated, with the historical view of human consciousness. 

    So there has been two phases in understanding art – the innocent acceptance of art (needed no defence or support outside itself) and secondly, the experienced justification of what it says or attempts to say. In this case art began needing support from outside to appreciate it. The theory of interpretation both makes and mars context as she believes that the task of interpretation is virtually one of translating through transforming. In reducing the work of art to its content, an interpreter “lames the work of art”. Sontag cites Thomas Mann as an over-cooperative author and “the mars ravishment” of Kafka. 

    By three armies of interpreters one citing is writing as a social allegory, the other as psychoanalytic allegory and the third as a religious allegory. Among the three interpretations, Kafka as Kafka is lost. In the same way, Samuel Beckett is read as an absurd world of man’s alienation from meaning or from God and from the psychological point of view looked on as an allegory of psycho-pathology. The numerous writers that Sontag cites show that interpretation has only undone the gestalt of a work. Answering the question, what kind of criticism or commentary on the arts is disabled today, Sontag begins saying that works of art are ineffable and cannot be described or paraphrased. 

    A work of art can be as Sontag believes that more attention to form in art should be given. She also asks for “a vocabulary of forms” that is like descriptive rather than prescriptive. Thirdly she finds equally valuable those criticisms which are accurate, sharp and feels the form of a work of an art. In conclusion Sontag advocates against looking at an interpreting art didactically or as a delight. What is needed according to her is to refine our senses “to see, more to hear more and to feel more”. If a reader learns to remove the content from focus, one will begin to see things as they are and as they should be. She closes with a very debatable punchline saying “in place of a hermeneutics we need and erotics of art”.